How should we set bids and targets on Amazon?
Our answer
Set each product's target advertising cost of sales (ACoS) from its margin. Cap starting bids at target ACoS times order value times conversion rate. Start on down-only bids, and raise bids or top-of-search increases only where data beats target.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 Amazon rules
- 3 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 4 sources
- 9 statements
- ASAOD
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentBid from your margin, not Amazon's suggested bid. SalesDuo, Olifant Digital and AMZDudes all set bids this way, and SalesDuo argues the suggested bid follows auction competition, not your profit.
Amazon's up and down bidding can double a bid on any placement. That is why SalesDuo and AMZDudes wait for 30 days or more of conversion data before switching it on.
A blanket bid cut can push you out of the placement that sells. Top of search beat product pages on ACoS in 82% of 63 accounts Olifant Digital (Amazon agency) manages.
Our judgment
- Set each product's target ACoS from its own margin and cap the starting bid at target ACoS times order value times conversion rate. SalesDuo, Olifant Digital and AMZDudes all use it, and Amazon says ACoS must stay below your profit margin.
- Launch on down-only bids, then move to up and down or fixed bids after about 30 days of conversions at or below target. SalesDuo requires 30 days of conversion data and AMZDudes 30 to 60 days, and Amazon's up and down can double the bid.
- Raise top-of-search adjustments in small steps only where the placement report beats target. Olifant Digital's account data favors top of search, while SalesDuo tests 50 to 150% and AMZDudes adds 10 to 20% at a time after 2 to 3 weeks of data.
- Change bids by no more than 20 to 25% at a time and wait one to two weeks before the next change. SalesDuo waits 7 to 14 days and AMZDudes a week. Amazon advises limiting changes while testing and reviewing about every two weeks.
Our judgment, built from SalesDuo, Olifant Digital, AMZDudes and Amazon: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
9 statements from 4 sourcesAmazon defines ACOS as ad spend divided by ad revenue and ROAS as its inverse. There is no set good ACOS, but to stay profitable it must sit below your profit margin.
“In order to maintain a profit, your Amazon ACOS needs to be lower than your profit margin.”
Amazon says up and down dynamic bidding can raise a Sponsored Products bid by up to 100% for all placements, so be ready to pay double. It suggests reviewing bids about every two weeks.
“Ensure you are prepared to potentially spend double the amount of the bid you input.”
Amazon advises adding manual campaigns beside automatic ones, separate campaigns or ad groups per product group, no end date, and placement bid adjustments of up to 900%.
“Take an always-on approach with your campaign by setting no end date.”
Amazon suggests starting Sponsored Products with an automatic campaign for about two weeks before adding manual ones, and testing match types for 1 to 2 weeks before pausing keywords.
“We recommend that you let your automatic campaign run for about two weeks before creating a manual campaign.”
Amazon says its free Seller Assistant can draft Sponsored Products campaigns and auto-adjust search terms under a seller's max bid; it claims a first sale 40% faster, with no method given.
“In early results, Amazon said, new campaigns using it saw a first sale 40 percent faster.”
Amazon's new dashboard suggests bid and budget actions advertisers can apply or skip; it says keyword auto-optimization beta campaigns got a first sale 40% faster and 13% more sales, with no control described.
“In beta testing, campaigns that adopted keyword auto-optimization saw a first sale 40% faster and a 13% increase in sales.”
Olifant Digital, an Amazon ad agency, says to anchor bids to contribution margin. In 63 accounts it manages, top of search had the lower ACoS in 82%, while off-Amazon placements ran 65% ACoS.
“Bid strategy should always be anchored to contribution margin.”
SalesDuo, an Amazon ad agency, says to use down-only bidding until a campaign has 30 days of conversion data, and gives its own bid formulas with no data shown.
“Amazon's suggested bid is based on auction competition, not your profitability targets.”
AMZDudes, an Amazon agency, says to set starting bids from margin (target ACoS times price times conversion rate), review weekly for 60 days, and raise placement bids in small steps only with data.
“Your starting bid should be calculated from your margin, not Amazon’s suggested range formula: Target ACoS × Product Price × Conversion Rate.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer