Should we use Amazon's automated bidding rules?
Our answer
Use Amazon's bid automation in steps. Run dynamic bids down only while a campaign learns, up and down after about 30 days of steady conversions, and rule-based bidding only for established campaigns with a clear ROAS goal.
- Confidence
- High
- Strongest proof
- 6 Amazon rules
- 1 practitioner, 7 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 14 statements
- ASAMJBIADAS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAmazon's bid automation settings suit different stages. Amazon says down only suits new advertisers and strict budgets, and up and down can raise a bid up to 100%. Rule-based bidding can lift bids up to 5 times to chase a ROAS goal it doesn't guarantee.
Switching dynamic bids to up and down too early wastes money. SalesDuo (Amazon agency) and AMZDudes both want at least 30 days of conversion data first. SalesDuo says switching earlier raises cost per click without more sales.
Set maximum bids, budgets and negatives before you automate. Merch Jar (Amazon ads software maker) and Big Internet Ecommerce set maximum bids, budgets and negatives first and change one setting at a time. They also decide whether Amazon may multiply bids your own rules set.
Our judgment
Move a campaign from down only to up and down, and only then to rule-based bidding, as its conversion history builds. That combines Amazon's account of who each strategy suits with the 30 days of conversion data SalesDuo and AMZDudes want. Keep Amazon's bid multipliers off campaigns that a third-party tool or your own rules already bid. Amazon's multiplier works on whatever bid your rules picked, and two systems adjusting one budget produce results neither intended. SellerSprite's view that manual bid management is dead doesn't change the answer. It shows no data, and its own table keeps search term harvesting, negatives and structure manual, as Big Internet Ecommerce does before automation.
Our judgment, built from Amazon, SalesDuo, AMZDudes, Merch Jar, Daniks.AI, SellerSprite and Big Internet Ecommerce: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
14 statements from 8 sourcesAmazon's Ads API guide says rule-based bidding needs a campaign running 10 days with 10 conversions in 30 days, and Amazon turns the rule off if return on ad spend falls below 30% of its earlier level.
“Your campaign must be running for at least 10 days prior to setting a rule and have a minimum of 10 conversions in the last 30 days.”
Amazon advises adding manual campaigns beside automatic ones, separate campaigns or ad groups per product group, no end date, and placement bid adjustments of up to 900%.
“Take an always-on approach with your campaign by setting no end date.”
Amazon's budget rules raise daily budgets for scheduled events or when a metric like ROAS meets a set value. Rules are reviewed daily and stack, so 40% plus 100% gives a 140% increase.
“If more than one rule meets the conditions, all applicable increases are cumulatively applied to the daily budget.”
Merch Jar, which sells Amazon ad automation, says down-only bidding is the safer default for thin margins or new keywords, up and down suits proven campaigns, and to change one lever at a time.
“Leave adjustments at 0% on new campaigns until there’s placement data to argue with.”
Big Internet Ecommerce, a PPC agency, says to set bid caps, budgets and negatives before Amazon's automation, and to test it against an identical campaign, judged on TACoS and profit after four weeks.
“Amazon’s tools grade Amazon’s own recommendations, so run control campaigns.”
Amazon explains Sponsored Products bidding: down only suits new advertisers and strict budgets; up and down can lift a $1.00 bid to $2.00 and suits products with good history. Fixed bids may bring fewer conversions.
“Amazon can adjust your bid of $1.00 up to $2.00 for all placements”
Amazon's new dashboard suggests bid and budget actions advertisers can apply or skip; it says keyword auto-optimization beta campaigns got a first sale 40% faster and 13% more sales, with no control described.
“In beta testing, campaigns that adopted keyword auto-optimization saw a first sale 40% faster and a 13% increase in sales.”
Amazon says CPCs usually rise in the weeks before and during Prime Day, Black Friday and Cyber Monday, and suggests raising bids then. Suggested bids reflect similar winning bids over the past 7 days.
“Higher CPCs typically occur in the weeks leading up to and during major shopping events such as Prime Day, Black Friday, and Cyber Monday.”
Daniks.AI, which sells ad automation, suggests event budget rules of +50% to +100% starting a day early, only on campaigns actually capped by budget, and not running rules beside an automation tool.
“Check whether the campaign is actually budget-capped before writing a rule for it.”
AMZBase, which earns affiliate fees on tools, says Amazon PPC software rarely pays back below about $2,000 to $3,000 a month in ad spend, and Amazon's free bidding features cover most of the value.
“Automation amplifies a structure.”
Amazon's rule-based bidding can raise bids up to 5 times to chase a ROAS target, without guaranteeing it; wait two weeks before setting one. Schedule rules raise bids at set times and stack.
“Amazon does not guarantee that we’ll hit the performance target that you set.”
SalesDuo, an Amazon agency, says switching to up-and-down bidding too early raises costs without sales, and in its audits sees sellers staying on down-only too long. No data shown.
“The result is higher CPCs without a corresponding increase in sales.”
SellerSprite, which sells Amazon research tools, says manual bid management is dead and to layer dynamic and fixed bids, but keeps search term harvesting, negatives and campaign structure manual.
“Basic bid automation is now a free native feature.”
AMZDudes, an Amazon ad agency, says dynamic bids down only is the safest default while learning; switch to up and down after 30+ days of consistent conversion, and use fixed bids for controlled tests.
“Switch to ‘up and down’ only when you have 30+ days of data showing consistent conversion rates.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer