When should we redesign the whole store versus improving it page by page?
Our answer
Improve the store page by page where shoppers drop off. Save a full redesign for when the theme itself is the limit, then test the new design with users and against the old theme.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 2 official rules
- 6 practitioners
- Sources
- 5 sources
- 8 statements
BCSSC
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA full redesign is rarely the first fix. Early redesigns add risk, cost and disruption to search rankings, says Blend Commerce (Shopify CRO agency), which sells redesigns itself.
Tweaking key templates can lift conversion without starting over. A Shopify Plus agency has seen layout tests on key templates lift conversion by as much as 10% or even 15% (reported by Shoplift, Shopify A/B testing app).
An untested redesign can ship months of work that performs worse than what it replaces. Speero (CRO and research consultancy) and Shoplift test a redesign before and during the build for that reason.
Our judgment
Make page by page improvement the default and a full redesign the exception. That combines Blend Commerce's advice to optimize before redesigning, the template layout test lifts reported through Shoplift and Charle's point that design and cart problems are not automatically platform problems. A/B test a new theme against the current one before switching all traffic, using Shopify's Rollouts theme tests. Judge a planned redesign against the current store after a period of focused fixes, not against the store as it is, applying to a redesign the comparison Charle sets for platform moves.
Our judgment, built from Blend Commerce, Shoplift, Charle, Shopify and Speero: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
8 statements from 5 sourcesShopify's built-in Experiments need the Grow plan or higher and cannot test headless checkouts or Liquid template changes. During a test, ads and feeds may show a different offer from the store.
“Product ads, listings, feeds, and third-party apps might not display the same offer.”
Speero, a testing agency, suggests validating a redesign before building it: five-second, preference and copy tests, then usability sessions, then a live A/B test.
“This recipe front-loads the validation.”
Shoplift, which sells Shopify A/B testing, says keep running behavioral and messaging tests during a redesign and pause only design-layer tests. A quoted agency recalls layout test lifts of 10% to 15%.
“Design-layer tests are the ones that genuinely don't survive a rebrand.”
Shoplift, which sells A/B testing software, says even a better rebuilt site causes short-term friction as returning customers lose their mental map, and recovery after a replatform takes 60 to 180 days.
“Even when the new Shopify product pages and checkout are measurably better than what they replaced, the change itself causes short-term friction.”
Blend Commerce, which sells both CRO and redesigns, advises optimizing a Shopify store before redesigning it, unless the theme itself is bloated, outdated or not built mobile-first.
“a full redesign is rarely the first or best solution.”
Charle, which sells Shopify builds, says many site problems are not platform problems, and a theme rebuild plus app audit typically costs a tenth to a third of a replatform with no traffic at risk.
“None of them is automatically a platform problem.”
Blend Commerce says one client's CRO-led Shopify redesign lifted conversion rate from 0.51% to 1.6%, but as a before and after with shifting traffic, it calls this an early signal, not proof.
“these results should be treated as early conversion-efficiency signals rather than a claim that the redesign alone drove every commercial movement”
Shopify's Rollouts, under Markets > Rollouts in the admin, can schedule, gradually publish and A/B test themes, checkout and customer account setups, including two entirely different themes.
“between two entirely different themes or checkout setups to find the winner”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it1 figure from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer
Read next
More in Platform and build- Should we stay on Shopify or move to another platform at our size?
- How should we migrate to Shopify from another platform without losing search traffic?
- How often should we update our theme to Shopify's newest version?
- Should we use Shopify's built-in features for bundles, subscriptions and reviews, or apps?