Should we use Shopify's built-in features for bundles, subscriptions and reviews, or apps?
Our answer
Use Shopify's free Bundles and Subscriptions apps for fixed bundles and plain subscribe and save. Add an app for mix-and-match bundles, bundles sold with subscriptions and reviews on your own product pages.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 8 official rules
- 7 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 15 statements
BFEWHAC
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentThe free Bundles app covers fixed sets only. It makes fixed bundles and multipacks, and bundles don't work with subscriptions, pre-orders or the Shopify Subscriptions app (Shopify).
App makers draw the same line. BOGOS and EasySell, which sell bundle and upsell apps, and Wholesale Helper call the free app enough for a few simple fixed bundles. They send mix-and-match and subscription bundles to an app.
Stars on your product pages need a review app. Shopify's own reviews are left and shown in its Shop app, and Charle (Shopify agency) says Shopify retired its free reviews app in 2024.
Our judgment
Our line is to use the free Bundles app for a few fixed bundles and multipacks and move to a bundle app only for mix-and-match, build-a-box or bundles alongside subscriptions. Shopify lists those gaps, and BOGOS, EasySell, Fudge and Wholesale Helper agree. For reviews on your own pages, start on a free app tier, since Judge.me's App Store listing shows a free plan with unlimited reviews. When a built-in feature could replace an app you pay for, run both for 2 to 4 weeks before cancelling, applying Taylor Sicard's advice on native features and the 2 to 4 week measurement window BOGOS uses.
Our judgment, built from Shopify, BOGOS, EasySell, Fudge, Wholesale Helper, Charle and Taylor Sicard: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 8 sourcesShopify's free Bundles app handles fixed and multipack bundles on all plans. Mix-and-match needs third-party apps or Plus APIs, and bundles do not work with subscriptions or pre-orders.
“Bundles aren't compatible with the Shopify Subscriptions app.”
Shopify's free Bundles app rates 2.8 stars from 571 App Store reviews, 40% five-star and 23% one-star. It makes fixed bundles and multipacks with real-time inventory.
“Easily create fixed bundles and multipacks directly from the Shopify admin.”
Shopify's free Subscriptions app sets weekly, monthly or yearly auto-billed plans that customers can skip, pause or cancel, with several discount types and analytics.
Shopify says only customers who bought through the Shop app or your store can review a product in the Shop app, where reviews show publicly, and supported third-party app reviews can display there too.
“Only Shop customers that have purchased a product from you are allowed to submit a review.”
Shopify says every product shown in Shop can be reviewed with no opt-out, review requests can go out 1 to 180 days after delivery, and merchants can reply in up to 1,000 characters.
“You can't opt out of receiving product reviews if you sell products on Shop.”
Judge.me's Shopify App Store listing shows a 5.0 rating from 49,227 reviews and a free plan with unlimited reviews, photo reviews and Google rich snippets. A $15 a month plan adds AI replies and integrations.
“Unlimited product and store reviews”
Shopify's free Subscriptions app supports auto-billed weekly, monthly or yearly subscriptions with discounts and lets customers skip, pause or cancel. It is rated 3.8 from 910 reviews, 18% at 1 star.
“Allow your customers to cancel, skip, or pause subscriptions”
Shopify's free Bundles app makes fixed bundles of up to 30 components on any plan, but bundle prices don't update when component prices change, and discounts must include the parent bundle.
“When the price of one of the bundled products updates, either manually or from price imports, the bundle price doesn't update.”
Fudge, which sells a competing bundle tool, calls Shopify Bundles the free starting point for fixed sets but notes no mix-and-match or Subscriptions support, and warns about free tiers capped by revenue.
“Shopify Bundles is free and the right starting point for fixed sets - but uses the default product template and rates poorly (2.8 stars) on UX limitations.”
Charle, a Shopify agency, says Shopify retired its free Product Reviews app in 2024 and recommends moving reviews to Judge.me or Loox, noting Judge.me's free plan has unlimited review requests.
“We recommend exporting your existing reviews and moving to an app like Judge.me or Loox as soon as possible.”
BOGOS, which sells a bundle app, says Shopify's free Bundles app suits a handful of simple fixed bundles, lacking mix-and-match and tiered pricing. Start with 2 to 3 bundles and measure for 2 to 4 weeks.
“Good for stores with a handful of simple bundles.”
Taylor Sicard, a consultant, says when Shopify ships a native version of an app, run it against the app for two to four weeks with a holdout before canceling, and keep apps that sell depth.
“Do not cancel anything on day one.”
Wholesale Helper says Shopify's free Bundles app suits fixed bundles and multipacks, while mix-and-match, build-a-box, BOGO or subscription bundles need a third-party app.
“Shopify has its own free Shopify Bundles app, but it is mainly useful for fixed bundles and multipacks.”
AgentReady's fee math at a $50 order: at $100,000 a month in subscriptions, Loop costs about $1,149, Skio $1,999 and Recharge $2,219. Under about $10,000 a month, Appstle or Seal is cheaper.
“Skio's flat $599 makes it overkill below roughly $30,000 a month and increasingly fair above it.”
EasySell, an upsell app seller, says Shopify's free Bundles app suits fewer than 10 fixed bundles with simple variants, and to switch to a third-party app at $7 to $50 a month for mix-and-match or subscriptions.
“Start free, upgrade when you hit a wall.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer