Which product feed changes improve Shopping and Performance Max results the most?
Our answer
Rewrite product titles first, with brand, product type and searched attributes inside the first 70 characters. Then fill every missing attribute, and add margin custom labels so campaigns can be split by margin.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 2 controlled tests
- 8 Google rules, 1 dataset, 4 practitioners, 5 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 12 sources
- 20 statements
- G
O
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentTitles are the biggest feed lever. Store Growers and Jetfuel Agency both build them as brand, product type, then key attributes, front-loaded with the terms shoppers search. Google's apparel guide asks for the key details inside the first 70 characters.
Feed attributes write your Shopping ad text. AI Max for Shopping, and Performance Max, draw on attributes such as material, size and fit to write it (Common Thread Collective). Common Thread Collective and smec warn that sparse or messy feeds produce generic copy.
Margin custom labels come next. One ROAS target across mixed margins lets the system favor the easiest products (Store Growers, Jetfuel Agency). Even with a clean feed, smec sees Performance Max drift to low margin items.
Our judgment
- Lead with titles, then attributes, then margin custom labels. Store Growers and Jetfuel Agency both rank titles first and margin labels high, and Google asks for the key title details early. FeedOptimizer.AI's attribute-first view rests on its own completeness score with no sales outcome.
- Fill attributes before turning on AI Max or relying on Performance Max ad text. Both draw on feed attributes to write Shopping ad copy, and Google's Merchant Center team asks merchants to use the full feed spec.
- Test a big feed change on one product segment against a control. This combines Common Thread Collective's four-week controlled test with smec's advice to test on a defined category or margin tier.
- Apply the 70 character title rule to every category. It comes from Google's apparel guide but matches the title patterns Store Growers and Jetfuel Agency give for all products, and Echelonn front-loads titles for any product because Shopping results cut them off after about 70 characters.
Our judgment, built from Store Growers, Jetfuel Agency, Google, FeedOptimizer.AI, Common Thread Collective, smec (Smarter Ecommerce) and Echelonn: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
20 statements from 12 sourcesGoogle says products flagged for low image quality keep showing in ads and free listings, but that image quality correlates strongly with clicks. No figures given.
“High image quality correlates strongly with user engagement and clicks”
Google requires product images of at least 500 x 500 pixels for all products from January 31, 2027, and recommends 1500x1500 pixels or larger for best performance.
“recently announced new image size requirements of at least 500 x 500 pixels for all products beginning January 31, 2027”
Google says leaving out a product's assigned GTIN can limit its visibility and performance, since identifiers help match searches to products, and incorrect identifiers can get products disapproved.
“Products with an assigned GTIN, but submitted without one, may have limited visibility”
Google Merchant Center says a supplemental data source can only add or update attributes for existing products, matched by exact product ID; only primary sources can add or remove products.
“Primary data sources are the only data source type that can add or remove products.”
PPC Land relays a Google notice that the Merchant Center warranty attribute is optional, though it may be required under local rules such as Quebec's Bill 29. Merchants stay responsible for compliance.
“Providing the warranty attribute for products in Google Merchant Center is optional”
Google's apparel feed tips, in priority order: images at least 512x512 (ideally 1024 or higher), key details in the first 70 characters of titles, consistent color names, and categories 2 to 3 levels deep.
“Include the most important product details within the first 70 characters of the title”
Product Metrics orders 12 Shopping feed fixes by tier, eligibility first, then relevance, not by measured impact. Its only figures are Google's older 20% click gain for correct GTINs and a 2018 to 2019 title case.
“Fix price, stock and policy issues before testing titles or images.”
PPC Land reports Google rewrote its low image quality help page; the old text said flagged products could be kept out of ads and free listings. Google gives no quality threshold and no word on ad rank.
“Google gives no figure for how much performance improves, and no threshold that separates acceptable images from poor ones.”
Google's Anric Durrani says AI Max for Shopping uses the product feed as a seed to tailor listings, featuring product details that fit the search.
“It uses your product feed as a seed to develop AI-performance creative”
In a vendor-run split test at Adorama, AI-enriched Google feed content lifted clicks 12.4% and cut CPC 3.5%. Conversion value rose 20.4% and ROAS 8.8%, but those gains were not confirmed as significant.
“Not every conversion and ROAS metric reached statistical significance inside the test window”
Joey Biddner says product titles, descriptions, GTINs and Google product categories are still the core of Merchant Center feed work, with the new conversational attributes secondary.
“these are still the bread and butter of merchant center”
Lily AI, which sells product feed rewriting, says a product-split test with a 28-day holdout raised Google Shopping revenue 28% from changing only product language. No product counts or confidence intervals given.
“It does not prove that rewriting your catalog will produce 28%”
PPC Land reports Google will disapprove product images under 500 x 500 pixels from 31 January 2027, following its April 2026 spec update. Smaller images already draw Image too small warnings.
“Google blocks product images under 500 x 500 pixels from 31 January 2027”
A Google Merchant Center product manager says merchants should use the full feed spec, including the newer conversational attributes Google introduced.
“leverage the full breadth of the feed spec that we offer, including the newer attributes that we have introduced, which is conversational attributes”
Jetfuel, which sells feed audits, says product titles are the most valuable Shopping feed fix (front-load the main search term), missing GTINs cost impression share and ratings, and changes show in 3 to 7 days.
“Product title structure is the single most valuable feed optimization. Front-load the most relevant search term.”
FeedOptimizer.AI, which sells feed software, scored 487,355 products across 290 feeds and found an average quality score of 55.9 out of 100. It advises checking attributes before titles. About 91% are Swiss.
“Check attributes and GPC before titles.”
CTC, an agency, relays Google's claim that AI Max for Shopping averages 5% more conversions at similar cost, and advises filling every feed attribute and testing four weeks against a control.
“Run a four-week test against a control campaign and measure conversion rate and ROAS at the campaign level before expanding.”
Store Growers, which sells Google Ads courses, calls the product feed the most important Performance Max input, starting with product titles, and wants 60 to 80% of spend on Shopping.
“Your product feed is the single most important input to a Performance Max campaign.”
Jackson Blackledge, Echelonn's founder, says to front-load Shopping product titles with the most important keywords rather than brand names, since titles get cut off after about 70 characters.
“I would say really, really front-load your titles. Put the most important keywords at the very beginning”
smec, which sells Shopping and Performance Max tools, says AI Max text customization is only as good as the feed and PMax spends on low-margin items with easy clicks; test it on one segment first.
“If your feed is messy, your AI-generated copy will be garbage.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer