Should we use Pinterest's Performance+ campaigns?
Our answer
Use Performance+ for Pinterest sales once you get about 50 conversions a week. Launch it as a new campaign beside your standard one, A/B test the two, and keep whichever wins on incremental revenue.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 8 official rules
- 1 dataset, 5 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 17 statements
- PBP
SPTTE
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentPerformance+ needs volume and a fresh start. Pinterest says Performance+ Leads and Sales campaigns perform best with 50 or more conversion events a week, and that an existing campaign cannot be converted to it.
Performance+ does well in independent measurement. Measured (incrementality testing firm) found the best Pinterest programs, including Performance+ formats, at 2 to 3.5 times its benchmark. Simple Pin Media and Trackbee start stores on it.
The biggest gains are Pinterest's own figures, such as nearly 80% in its own A/B testing. Pinterest itself tells advertisers to A/B test their setup and keep the one that tests better.
Our judgment
- Use Performance+ for sales campaigns once conversions reach about 50 a week, but prove it with an A/B test. Measured's panel and agency practice favor it, while the large gains come from Pinterest itself and its optimization score help page advises A/B testing your setup.
- Below 50 conversions a week, keep a standard Sales campaign rather than moving to Consideration as Pinterest suggests. Measured found Pinterest traffic buys pooled near zero (Pinterest objective for sales). Bring in Performance+ once volume builds, as Tailored Edge Marketing and Black Propeller advise.
- Run the A/B test at least four weeks. Pinterest's learning mode alone takes about two weeks on average, and How long a small-channel test should run sets four weeks as the floor for a test on a smaller channel.
- Treat the optimization score as a setup checklist, not evidence of results. Pinterest notes it is no guarantee, and ContentGrip points out that a higher score does not prove a better outcome.
Our judgment, built from Pinterest, Measured, Simple Pin Media, Trackbee, Black Propeller, Tailored Edge Marketing and ContentGrip: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
17 statements from 7 sourcesPinterest recommends Performance+ budgets at 5x the CPA goal, 10+ ads per ad group, and 50+ conversions a week for Sales or Leads; under 50, start with Consideration. Learning takes about two weeks.
“We recommend an investment 5 times above your cost per acquisition goal”
Pinterest says its Performance+ campaigns have no minimum budget and need 50% fewer inputs than standard setup; ROAS bidding needs its tag or Conversions API passing revenue.
“No, there is not a minimum budget.”
Pinterest says an existing campaign cannot be converted to Performance+; you start a new one and can turn it on for the campaign or setting by setting. Performance+ budgets flex 25% a day across a rolling 7-day average.
“The system flexes spend up or down by 25% per day, across a rolling 7-day average”
Pinterest says Performance+ is a toggle for Consideration, Leads or Sales campaigns, keeps some targeting such as keywords, locations and customer lists, and uses its own automated bidding.
“Activate Pinterest Performance+ campaigns with a toggle at the beginning of campaign creation for Consideration, Leads or Sales campaigns”
Pinterest says with Performance+ daily budgets it may spend up to 125% of the daily budget in one day, while averaging no more than the daily budget from Sunday to Saturday.
“We try our best to spend no more than 125% of your daily budget in a single day”
Pinterest says Performance+ campaigns beat traditional campaigns by nearly 80% in A/B testing and ROAS bidding raised return 10%. Test details are not on the page.
“In A/B testing, Pinterest Performance+ campaigns outperformed traditional campaigns by nearly 80%”
Pinterest's campaign optimization score runs 0 to 100 and starts at 90 or more by default; Pinterest says it is no guarantee, and a validly tested setup that beats it need not change.
“is not a guarantee of improved performance.”
Simple Pin Media, a Pinterest ads agency, says Pinterest ads work best for ecommerce shops with proven products, and it typically requires clients to commit $150 to $200 a day for at least three months.
“Erin typically won't take on a client who can't commit at least $150 to $200 per day, and that budget needs to run for a minimum of three months”
Tailored Edge Marketing, which sells paid social, tells new Shopify brands on Pinterest to start with one Sales campaign and few ad groups, often one prospecting group, splitting only when economics differ.
“Every ad group should answer a commercial question that could change the next decision.”
ContentGrip says Pinterest has not explained the formula behind its campaign optimization score, and a 10%+ CPC and CPA gain in Pinterest's test does not prove moving the score from 70 to 90 will do the same.
“It does not prove that moving an optimization score from, for example, 70 to 90 will produce the same effect.”
Pinterest says higher campaign optimization scores correlate with better campaign performance across all objectives, and urges full use of Performance+ and broad audiences. Pinterest is grading its own product.
“Across all objectives, we've seen that higher campaign optimisation scores correlate to better campaign performance.”
Pinterest announced self-serve A/B testing across creative, targeting and Performance+, plus Visual Search Ads in beta for lower-funnel objectives.
“support lower funnel objectives and are compatible with Pinterest Performance+”
Measured's panel of enterprise consumer brands indexed Pinterest at 1.1x the panel average, with catalog, DPA and Performance+ formats reaching 2x to 3.5x. Traffic and awareness buys pooled near zero.
“It rarely produced the panel's top line item, but it almost never produced a disaster either.”
Black Propeller, which sells paid social management, says Pinterest Performance+ now consistently beats manual campaigns on CPA for ecommerce with enough volume. The 28% lower CPA is Pinterest's own figure, relayed.
“For ecommerce brands with sufficient conversion volume, it now consistently outperforms manually managed campaigns on CPA.”
Black Propeller, which sells paid social management, advises separate Pinterest ad groups for prospecting, retargeting and re-engagement, and 30 to 50 conversions a week before automated bidding.
“Avoid making significant changes to budgets, bids, or targeting within the first seven days of any new campaign.”
Trackbee, which sells Pinterest conversion tracking, says Pinterest clicks and impressions often cost 30 to 50% less than Meta, and to test two to four weeks at a daily budget 4 to 5 times target CPA.
“works best as a complementary top and mid-funnel channel rather than a Meta replacement”
Pinterest launched a new customer option in Performance+ that values new customers higher, and claims early testers saw 64% more new-customer conversions and small businesses 28% better ROAS.
“Assign a higher value to new customers through value rules”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer