Should we pay for digital PR to earn links?
Our answer
Pay for digital PR only when you have data or a story your category's publications would cover and the basics are done. Run one campaign as a trial judged on revenue. Never pay an outlet for followed links.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 official rule
- 7 datasets, 1 practitioner, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 12 statements
- B
GMRJ1AW
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentDigital PR is expensive for a small business. A campaign costs $5,000 to $10,000 for about 6 to 7 linking domains (BuzzStream, link building software maker). A typical UK retainer would use up most UK small businesses' yearly marketing budget in weeks (Whito).
Earned coverage gets cited, and paid placement does not. Earned media is 84% of AI citations and paid content 0.3% (Muck Rack), and wire press releases are barely cited (BuzzStream). Google treats paid articles whose links pass ranking credit as link spam.
A campaign built around commercial pages can pay. JBH, a digital PR agency, reports in an award entry that 72% of its Cosmetify campaign's links went to commercial pages and that revenue rose.
Our judgment
- Fund one campaign as a trial before signing a retainer. Judge it over about 6 months on links to the pages you sell from, coverage and revenue or enquiries. We drew that from BuzzStream's campaign pricing, the 85.2% of practitioners in its survey who say measurable results come within 6 months, JBH's revenue-judged Cosmetify campaign and Whito's advice to judge link spending by enquiries and revenue, not link counts.
- Pay only once the free link work and your site's basics are done and you have a story or data worth covering. Whito likens paying for links before the basics to paying for the roof before the walls. Coverage in a store's own niche worked best, and pitching data-led content is the most common tactic.
- Pay for research, writing and pitching, never for the placement or wire distribution. Google's link spam rule covers paid press releases too. Syndicated press releases are 0.04% of AI citations in BuzzStream's data.
- Count coverage that names you without a link as part of the return, and repeat a campaign that works within the year. Brand mentions track AI visibility more closely than links (Ahrefs), and more than half of journalism citations come from articles published in the past 12 months.
Our judgment, built from BuzzStream, JBH, Whito, 1Digital, Google, Muck Rack and Ahrefs: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
12 statements from 9 sourcesBuzzStream, which sells outreach software, prices digital PR at $1,250 to $1,500 per unique link, and says a $5,000 to $10,000 campaign typically nets 6 to 7 unique linking root domains.
“Digital PR earns links instead of buying them.”
BuzzStream, which sells outreach software, puts average link insertion at $179, guest posts at $295 to $461, and digital PR at $1,250 to $1,500 per link. Paid followed links break Google's spam policy.
“Earned placements cost the most per link”
1Digital, an SEO agency, says in its unaudited study of 10,000 Shopify stores that referring domains correlated more with rankings (0.59) than raw backlink count (0.38).
“Target five to ten topically relevant publications per quarter over generic link-building campaigns.”
Google counts paid articles, guest posts or press releases with links that pass ranking credit as link spam, but says paid links are fine when marked rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored".
“It's not a violation of our policies to have such links as long as they are qualified with a rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored" attribute value to the <a> tag.”
Whito, which sells no links, says UK link building retainers of £1,000 to £2,500 a month exceed most small business budgets, and local firms should earn reviews, press and directory mentions instead.
“If you are a local business, the evidence in this report points away from bought links entirely.”
JBH, a digital PR agency, claims its award-entered campaign for Cosmetify won 125 links at £96 each from a £12,000 budget, with revenue up 162% and traffic up 74%. One UK beauty site; not independently audited.
“The campaign generated 125 high-quality links, 72% pointing to commercial pages, at a cost per link of just £96.”
Muck Rack, which sells PR software, found across 25 million links that earned media (broadly defined) makes up 84% of AI citations and paid content 0.3%. Journalism alone is 27%, mostly recent articles.
“Paid and advertorial content represents just 0.3% of citations.”
Visionary Marketing, which sells SEO outreach, finds a 0.74 correlation between referring domains and rank in its 50,000-page analysis, and says topically relevant links beat more mixed-topic ones.
“This does not mean 'buy more links'.”
BuzzStream, which sells PR software, found news sites made up 14% of 4 million AI citations over one week, while newswire press releases were just 0.21% of all citations.
“So, the suggestion that you can just put out a press release on a newswire doesn't seem like it will get you any exposure in AI.”
Editorial.Link, which sells link building, surveyed 518 SEO pros: 48.6% rate digital PR the top tactic, the average acceptable price per quality backlink is $508.95, and 57.1% expect results in 1 to 3 months.
BuzzStream, which sells outreach software, surveyed 150+ digital PR pros: about 60% spend under $10,000 a month, the common cost per link is $300 to 500, and 85.8% call link building most effective. Self-reported.
“The most common range for known average cost per link is $300-500 (19.6%).”
Ahrefs, which sells an AI mention tracker, found across 75,000 brands that YouTube mentions (about 0.737) and branded web mentions correlate most with AI visibility, while backlinks barely do.
“What matters most is getting mentioned across a broad scope of sites.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer