All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

How should we handle bad or spammy links pointing to our site?

The PrevailingPublished Oct 28, 2026

Our answer

Leave spammy links you did not build alone and ignore tool toxic scores. Disavow only if you or your SEO bought links or you have an unnatural links manual action, after asking sites to remove them.

Confidence
High
Strongest proof
8 official rules
1 practitioner, 5 opinions or claims
Sources
6 sources
14 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Most sites won't need the disavow tool. Google's help says it is for many spammy links that caused or will likely cause a manual action, and that used wrongly it can harm your rankings.

Spam links dropped into comments have no effect either way, John Mueller of Google said in January 2026. In March he added that most sites don't need a disavow file, though not all.

A spam wave did no visible harm in one case. SEO-Kreativ's blog took more than 60 nofollow spam links in six days with no drop in Search Console clicks or position. It calls a tool's toxic label a heuristic, not a Google verdict.

Our judgment

  • Judge the risk from the Manual actions report, not a toxicity score. Google typically ignores known spam sites, Mueller said spam links dropped into comments have no effect, and SEO-Kreativ saw no drop after its spam wave, so we read Search Console's report as the better signal.
  • Treat a disavow file as cleanup for links you or a hired SEO built. Google ties the tool to manual actions, Mueller's September 2026 case involved a site tied to bought links, and Glenn Gabe (SEO consultant) says a site with no manual action and no unnatural links of its own should never need one.
  • John Mueller of Google said in March 2026 that a disavow file is fine if you are conflicted, even for a whole TLD. That does not change the advice to leave spammy links you did not build alone. Google's help still reserves the tool for links that caused or will likely cause a manual action and warns it can harm a site, and Glenn Gabe calls TLD-level disavowing excessive.
  • A toxic label alone is no reason to disavow. Semrush's toxicity markers can help spot a link network you may have bought into. SEO-Kreativ calls the label a tool heuristic, and Semrush itself asks for careful manual review first.

Our judgment, built from Google, John Mueller, SEO-Kreativ, Glenn Gabe and Semrush: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

14 statements from 6 sources
  • GoogleUndatedSupports

    Google says most sites never need its disavow links tool, and to use it only for many spammy links that caused or may cause a manual action. Misuse can harm search performance.

    “In most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most sites will not need to use this tool.”

    Read it on support.google.com

  • GoogleUndatedCaveat

    Google says the Search Console Links report shows only a sample of links. Google typically ignores links from known spam sites, though it says you might still remove or disavow them.

    “For known spam sites, Google typically will ignore the links, but you might want to remove or disavow these links.”

    Read it on support.google.com

  • SemrushUndatedDisagrees

    Semrush, which sells the tool, says its Backlink Audit flags links with 45+ toxic markers for removal or disavow, and advises reviewing each flagged link manually. It describes its tool, not Google's treatment.

    “Manually review with the utmost care each backlink marked as toxic/potentially toxic before starting the removal process”

    Read it on semrush.com

  • GoogleUndatedSupports

    Google says a manual action must be fixed on every affected page, since partial fixes earn no partial return, and a reconsideration request should explain the issue, the fix and the result. Reviews take days or weeks.

    “Fixing the issue on just some pages will not earn you a partial return to search results.”

    Read it on support.google.com

  • Search Engine RoundtableOct 8, 2026Caveat

    Search Engine Roundtable reports SEO consultants seeing more Google manual action penalties in 2026, for thin content, pure spam and scaled content, often on long-standing businesses. No counts given.

    “Went from essentially no requests to several per week.”

    Read it on seroundtable.com

  • Google2026-10Caveat

    Google says that after a link spam update, any ranking benefit the spammy links gave is gone and cannot be regained, so changes may not bring an improvement.

    “Any potential ranking benefits generated by those links cannot be regained.”

    Read it on developers.google.com

  • Search Engine RoundtableSep 2, 2026Caveat

    Google's John Mueller says the disavow tool does have effects but disavowing a handful of links won't sink a site, and recovery from big algorithm changes can take many months. The case involved bought links.

    “There's a lot of hate on the disavow tool here - but it has its place & time, it does have effects.”

    Read it on seroundtable.com

  • Search Engine RoundtableAug 31, 2026Supports

    Google's John Mueller says a site is not penalized for old outbound links to domains that later turn shady. Search Engine Roundtable notes Google has ignored, not demoted, such links since 2016.

    “No. It's good to keep things fresh overall, but the web is full of turmoil.”

    Read it on seroundtable.com

  • GoogleAug 28, 2026Caveat

    Google's spam policy counts paying for links, trading goods for links, or sending a product in exchange for a post with a link as link spam, unless the link is marked nofollow or sponsored.

    “Sending someone a product in exchange for them writing about it and including a link”

    Read it on developers.google.com

  • WhitoAug 23, 2026Supports

    Whito, which sells research files, summarizes that Google's SpamBrain has neutralized paid and manipulative links since December 2022, and that most sites don't need the disavow tool.

    “since the December 2022 link spam update, its SpamBrain system neutralises paid and manipulative links”

    Read it on whito.co.uk

  • SEO-KreativJun 7, 2026Supports

    An SEO consultant's own blog got about 70 nofollow spam backlinks in days; Search Console clicks rose from about 37 to 46 a day and no manual action appeared, so he did not disavow. One site, no control.

    Read it on seo-kreativ.de

  • Glenn GabeMar 11, 2026Supports

    Glenn Gabe, an SEO consultant, says Google ignores spammy links well, so a site without a manual action or links it built should never need to disavow. Google's John Mueller called disavowing a whole TLD a big hammer.

    “If you don’t have a manual action, didn’t set up unnatural links, etc., then you never should have to disavow any links.”

    Read it on seroundtable.com

  • Search Engine RoundtableMar 6, 2026Disagrees

    Google's John Mueller says most sites don't need a disavow file, but using one is fine if unsure, and a whole TLD can be disavowed. Google's disavow help page does not mention whole-TLD disavows.

    “Most sites don't need it, but that's not all sites.”

    Read it on seroundtable.com

  • Search Engine RoundtableJan 18, 2026Supports

    Google's John Mueller, relayed by Search Engine Roundtable, says spam links dropped into comments have no effect on a site, positive or negative.

    “These would not have any effect, positive nor negative, on your site.”

    Read it on seroundtable.com

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Links and authority