Should we create comparison and "best of" pages for our own products?
Our answer
Build honest comparison pages that help buyers choose, with your own testing, drawbacks and a reason for each pick. Don't publish “best” lists that rank your own product first.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 7 official rules
- 2 datasets, 4 practitioners, 6 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 19 statements
- G
LR
UFBAAPA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentGoogle allows a merchant to guide buyers between competing products. Its review guidance asks for first-hand evidence and a reason whenever something is called the best.
Self-ranking “best” lists cost software sites visibility. Lily Ray (SEO agency executive) traced visibility drops of 29% to 49% from January 2026 on sites full of them. Google's AI answers left the self-ranked brand out 69% of the time they cited its list.
Your own pages do more for a new brand than an established one. Answers citing Ahrefs' self-promotional pages held 82% of its new brand's new AI mentions, against 6% for its established brand. It advises adding yourself to the right contexts without crowning yourself.
Our judgment
- Build pages for the comparisons buyers make: your own models, your product against a named alternative, or two approaches. Google's review guidance allows it, the FTC encourages truthful comparisons that name competitors, and Branded Agency says owning these pages takes back traffic otherwise lost to affiliates and review sites.
- Don't publish “best” lists that rank your own product first, and never in bulk. Lily Ray's tracked sites lost visibility, ClickUp's blog with 249 self-first alternatives lists lost 97.6% of its traffic (Kamila Olexa), and Google's AI answers often recommended the rivals named instead. This outweighs Kevin Indig's and Peec's findings that many such lists still gain traffic or citations, since Scrunch's measured lift was modest and the losses in Lily Ray's tracking hit the blogs that carried the lists.
- In a roundup of your category, include yourself only where you fit and say you make the product. That follows Ahrefs' advice to add yourself to the right contexts without crowning yourself, and the FTC's call for clarity and disclosure in comparisons.
- Apply findings on lists that rank your own product first to stores and local businesses with care. Every measurement of self-ranking lists covered business software brands.
Our judgment, built from Google, US Federal Trade Commission, Branded Agency, Lily Ray, PPC Land, Kevin Indig, Peec AI and Ahrefs: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
19 statements from 10 sourcesThe FTC encourages ads that name competitors, as long as comparisons are clear, truthful and not deceptive, with disclosure where needed.
“The Commission has previously held that disparaging advertising is permissible so long as it is truthful and not deceptive.”
Google's John Mueller says cheap, fast tactics such as listicles used to rank in AI search will eventually be caught by Google's systems, so don't rely on them. No timing was given.
“eventually the systems will catch up, so don't use those cheap, easy, and fast tactics”
A University of Toronto study of 158,099 AI answers found ChatGPT consults 26 pages on average and cites 3, and at equal rank cites brand pages more (x1.71) than lists, comparisons or Reddit threads.
“at equal rank, concise pages from the original source win over roundups and forums.”
Lily Ray found Google's AI Overviews cite 38% fewer vendor-written best-of lists than in June, and the self-ranking brand was left out 83% of the time. One consultant's small software sample.
“These are a consultant's own measurements, on a small sample from one vertical and one AI surface.”
PPC Land relays Scrunch, an AI visibility vendor: a brand's self-ranking listicle, when cited, raised its AI recommendation rate from about 4% to 7%, but assistants recommended nobody in 63.9% of such answers.
“When cited, the lift from self-promoting listicles is real, if modest,”
Kevin Indig, an organic growth advisor, says that for listicle pages in Google, only freshness predicted top-three rankings; author bios, schema and word count did not. His data is behind a paywall.
“Only freshness predicted top-three rankings.”
Google's spam policy now defines spam to include attempts to manipulate generative AI responses in Google Search, not only rankings.
“attempting to manipulate generative AI responses in Google Search”
Google's spam policies ban pages mass-produced to manipulate rankings, including with AI tools and no added value, plus city doorway pages and copied affiliate descriptions. Such sites may rank lower or not appear.
“Using generative AI tools or other similar tools to generate many pages without adding value for users”
Google says its AI search features value first-hand reviews over summaries of existing content, and that chasing inauthentic mentions is not as helpful as it might seem, since spam systems also apply.
“a first-hand review provides a unique perspective based on personal experience, whereas a summary of existing content simply restates information already available elsewhere.”
Ahrefs tracked 34 of its own pages across 9,886 AI answers: for a new brand, 82% of new mentions came from answers citing its pages; for its established brand, only 6%. No control group.
“self-promotional content seems to help most when your brand is a believable answer to the query already.”
SEO consultant Lily Ray found, in Google AI Overviews for 100 software queries, that brands cited for their own "best" listicles were left out of the recommendation 69% of the time (224 of 323).
“If you're a smaller brand, though, you may actually be shooting yourself in the foot by publishing self-promotional listicles.”
Google's May 15, 2026 changelog clarified that its search spam policies apply to generative AI responses in Google Search too.
“To make it clear that the spam policies apply to all of Google Search, including generative AI responses.”
Lily Ray, who sells SEO recovery work, says 54% of 220+ sites featured by AI content tools lost 30% or more of peak organic traffic after fast page growth. She blames how the tools are used, not the tools.
“Could a competitor publish a near-identical version of this page tomorrow using the same prompt?”
PPC Land reports a consultant's analysis estimating ClickUp's blog lost 97.6% of organic traffic in fifteen months, blamed partly on 249 alternatives listicles that all ranked ClickUp first.
“Every listicle on the blog places ClickUp at number one, even when the positioning is illogical.”
Peec, which sells AI visibility tracking, found self-promotional listicles drew about 11% of 232,000 AI citations in software reviews, with no sign of correction, yet advises earning third-party listicles instead.
“over the 12 weeks: rates stayed stable within natural variation, so any corrections brands see are case-by-case, not systemic.”
Lily Ray, an SEO consultant, says SaaS sites ranking themselves #1 in 'best' lists lost 29% to 49% of organic visibility from mid-January 2026; they used other risky tactics too, with no control group.
“tactics that prioritize self-promotion over genuine evaluation appear increasingly risky.”
Branded Agency, which sells Shopify SEO, says brands should own 'Brand A vs Brand B' comparison pages to take back traffic from affiliates and review sites. No data given.
“Shoppers now search “Brand A vs Brand B” before buying.”
Google's guidance for review content says to show evidence of first-hand experience, share measurements, explain what sets a product apart, and say why something is best, focusing on quality over length.
“When recommending something as the best overall or the best for a certain purpose, include why you consider it the best, with first-hand supporting evidence.”
Google's guidance for review content says to cover comparable options, discuss benefits and drawbacks from your own research, focus on key decision factors and link to useful resources.
“Discuss the benefits and drawbacks of something, based on your own original research.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer