How should we target searches that mention competitors?
Our answer
Answer searches that name a rival with fair comparison and alternatives pages on your own site. Build them only for the few rivals buyers really weigh you against. Don't publish lists that rank yourself first.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 6 official rules
- 1 dataset, 5 practitioners, 6 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 18 statements
GUF
BEE
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentPeople who search a rival's name with alternatives or a comparison are close to buying (PPC Land). Web Tonic says comparison searches convert 2 to 3 times better than bare brand names in most paid accounts.
Self-ranking lists lose ground in AI answers. Lily Ray found self-ranking "best" pages left their own brand out of 83% of the Google AI answers citing them, and Seer Interactive saw ChatGPT cut list page citations 30% in one month.
Google's review guidance and the US Federal Trade Commission reward honest comparisons. Google's review guidance asks for benefits and drawbacks from your own research, and the US Federal Trade Commission encourages naming rivals in comparisons that are clear and not deceptive.
Our judgment
- Build pages only for the rivals your buyers actually weigh you against. Twenty vendors make 190 pairings (PPC Land), Google says separate content for every search variation made to manipulate rankings breaks its scaled content abuse policy, and eSEOspace and Web Tonic both limit the list to the real decisions buyers face.
- Present your own product honestly rather than ranking it first. Ahrefs advises not to crown yourself, and even Grow and Convert, which defends these pages, agrees that ranking yourself best behind a claimed objective review is misleading.
- Compare against the alternatives buyers really consider. For a store that can include a cheaper copy, a do it yourself fix or doing nothing. For a local service business it is usually a choice between options rather than named local firms.
- Also work to be described fairly on the review sites and roundups that hold many of these searches, and keep a plain page about your own product. Independent directories remain the highest-traffic publishers of alternatives pages (PPC Land), and AI assistants cite brand pages more and comparison pages less (Mahe Chen and Nick Koudas).
Our judgment, built from PPC Land, Google, eSEOspace, Web Tonic, Lily Ray, Seer Interactive, Ahrefs, Grow and Convert, Blend Commerce and Mahe Chen and Nick Koudas: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
18 statements from 13 sourcesThe FTC's policy encourages naming competitors in comparative ads as long as the comparison is clear, and allows disparaging ads that are truthful and not deceptive.
“disparaging advertising is permissible so long as it is truthful and not deceptive.”
The UK CAP Code says superiority claims need evidence unless obvious puffery, and comparisons must be like for like, objective, clear on price basis and must not denigrate competitors.
“Superiority claims must be supported by evidence unless they are obvious puffery”
eSEOspace, an SEO agency, says comparison pages must keep claims about rivals true and checkable, compare like with like, and admit when the other option wins; local firms can compare approaches instead of brands.
“Include the cases where the other option is the better choice.”
A University of Toronto study of 158,099 AI answers found ChatGPT consults 26 pages on average and cites 3, and at equal rank cites brand pages more (x1.71) than lists, comparisons or Reddit threads.
“at equal rank, concise pages from the original source win over roundups and forums.”
Lily Ray found Google's AI Overviews cite 38% fewer vendor-written best-of lists than in June, and the self-ranking brand was left out 83% of the time. One consultant's small software sample.
“These are a consultant's own measurements, on a small sample from one vertical and one AI surface.”
PPC Land says people searching a brand plus "alternatives" are ready to choose, vendors ranking themselves first must back the claim, and reported drops for self-ranking pages are unconfirmed by Google.
“A vendor ranking itself first makes a comparative superiority claim, which United States advertising law treats as requiring substantiation.”
PPC Land says versus pages catch high-intent, low-volume demand, but mass-produced pairings keep colliding with spam policy, and EU rules require comparisons to be verifiable and not misleading.
“Verifiability is the condition most versus pages struggle with.”
Web Tonic, a PPC agency, says bidding on rivals' brand names costs 2-4x your own brand CPC, so pick 5-10 rivals you lose deals to, set a 90-day cap and kill line, and keep your own brand campaign funded.
“Bidding on the pure brand name of a market leader is the version of the tactic that burns money quietly.”
Ahrefs tracked 34 of its own pages across 9,886 AI answers: for a new brand, 82% of new mentions came from answers citing its pages; for its established brand, only 6%. No control group.
“self-promotional content seems to help most when your brand is a believable answer to the query already.”
Blend Commerce's Peter Gardner says stores should build comparison pages against rivals, cheaper dupes, DIY options and doing nothing, saying who should and shouldn't buy.
“The purpose of a Battle Card is not to pick fights but make the decision easier for your customers.”
Pushes back on a listicle crackdown: Grow and Convert, which writes such posts, says Google targets bad content, not self-promotional lists, citing six client posts tracked in Ahrefs.
“we see no evidence of Google cracking down on self-promotional listicles.”
Google's guide says making separate content for every query variation, mainly to manipulate rankings or AI answers, violates its scaled content abuse policy. It also says a high page count does not make a site better.
“a high quantity of pages doesn't make a website higher quality or more relevant to users.”
Echelonn, which sells Google Ads management, says ecommerce brands should test comparison keywords such as competitor reviews and alternatives; it cites client campaigns at 3.7 and 2.7 platform ROAS.
“That’s why I believe every ecom brand should test comparison keywords.”
Seer Interactive, which sells AI search services, found ChatGPT citations of list pages fell 30% from December to January while holding in AI Overviews; lists backed by outside data grew most.
“The listicles growing the most in AI citations over the period included external signals (like G2 ratings or government data) or thorough methodologies to validate their reasoning.”
Backlinko, owned by SEO tool seller Semrush, says comparison keywords draw advanced searchers with little competition, citing one example term it ranked top 3 quickly.
“comparison keywords don't usually have a ton of competition.”
Google's guidance for review content says to show evidence of first-hand experience, share measurements, explain what sets a product apart, and say why something is best, focusing on quality over length.
“When recommending something as the best overall or the best for a certain purpose, include why you consider it the best, with first-hand supporting evidence.”
Google's guidance for review content says to cover comparable options, discuss benefits and drawbacks from your own research, focus on key decision factors and link to useful resources.
“Discuss the benefits and drawbacks of something, based on your own original research.”
The FTC rule bars a business from misrepresenting that a review website or organization it controls, owns or operates gives independent reviews or opinions. In force since October 21, 2024.
“materially misrepresent, expressly or by implication, that a website, organization, or entity that it controls, owns, or operates provides independent reviews or opinions”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer