Should sale and promotion ads run inside evergreen ad sets with pushed delivery, or in separate time-bound promotion campaigns?
Our answer
Run sales in separate time-bound campaigns, scheduled before the sale and paused between events. Push budget to promotion ads inside an evergreen ad set only for a short promotion on products it already sells, not for Black Friday.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 6 Meta rules
- 10 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 18 statements
- M
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAgencies at large spend keep sales in their own campaigns. Flighted, Common Thread Collective, Phil Kiel and Andrew Faris all do. Flighted says sale spikes skew learning in your core campaigns. Faris schedules sale ads ahead with their own budgets and bid controls.
Adding sale ads to a running ad set restarts its learning. Meta counts a new ad as a significant edit, and says ad sets in learning are less stable and usually have a higher cost per purchase.
Two sources add sale ads to running campaigns instead, without results. Darkroom, a paid media agency, adds Black Friday ads only to campaigns already running so they don't learn from scratch. Jon Loomer, a Meta ads educator, would push budget to a short promotion's ads.
Our judgment
- Sales go in separate time-bound campaigns. The three agencies at large spend and Andrew Faris agree, while Darkroom's running-campaign approach and Loomer's push delivery come without results.
- Push delivery fits only a short promotion on products an ad set already sells, the case Loomer describes. A Black Friday to Cyber Monday sale is a planned sale window, not a short promotion, so it gets its own campaign, even though it runs about as long as Loomer's seven-day example and despite Darkroom's practice.
- Meta's significant edit rule tips planned sales toward their own campaigns. Each push of new ads into an evergreen ad set restarts its learning, while a separate campaign keeps that cost inside the sale.
- Schedule the sale campaign and launch it as early as the sale allows. Getting its ads approved before the sale meets Darkroom's concern about learning from scratch, and launching early applies Meta's holiday advice to begin campaigns early (for Black Friday dates, Budgets and launch timing for seasonal peaks).
- Run a short sale's campaign on automatic bids. Andrew Faris uses automatic bids for short sales or few purchases, and Phil Kiel uses no manual bids on the BFCM campaign.
Our judgment, built from Flighted, Common Thread Collective, Phil Kiel, Andrew Faris, Darkroom, Jon Loomer and Meta: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
18 statements from 9 sourcesMeta says ad sets exit the learning phase after about 50 results in a week, warns that many ads and ad sets slow learning, and recommends combining similar ad sets.
Meta says targeting, creative or optimization event changes and adding a new ad are always significant edits, while a budget change may or may not restart learning, depending on its size. No safe percentage is given.
“if you increase your budget from $100 to $101, that isn't likely to cause one or more ad sets to reenter the learning phase.”
Meta says ad sets in the learning phase are less stable and usually cost more per result, so wait to edit until learning ends and avoid frequent budget changes, but do not try to avoid learning entirely.
“During the learning phase, ad sets are less stable and usually have a higher CPA.”
CTC reports Meta's new reserved buys, Super Burst (a 3 to 24 hour reach window) and a US test of First Impression Ads, sold through Meta's managed team. It gives no prices or reach figures.
“These formats are additive to your existing campaign structure.”
AdExchanger reports Meta's Super Burst, now generally available, reserves reach on a single day within 5% of forecast at a frequency of one, with CPMs varying by date and US category exclusivity on some tentpole dates.
“Meta commits to generate a specific amount of reach, within 5% of a set forecast.”
Meta's Ads Super Burst lets advertisers book a 3 to 24 hour window at TV-like reach, with category exclusivity and guaranteed delivery, rolling out in phases to general availability in October 2026.
“Ads Super Burst lets you book a window of 3 to 24 hours and reach your audience at TV-like scale inside that window”
Phil Kiel, whose agency buys media, says to run a separate Black Friday campaign without manual bids, load budgets at midnight, watch Shopify hourly since recent Ads Manager hours are partial, and check your credit line.
“Check your Meta credit line today. If it can't carry the weekend, delivery stops mid-sale.”
Fraser Cottrell's Black Friday advice from CPG accounts: add a sale banner to your top 5 evergreen ads, run lots of offer-led statics, and keep making evergreen ads with one Black Friday variation.
A practitioner with no data says to put Black Friday ads into campaigns already running, stop creating new ones about ten days out, and launch early-access ads early so they get through learning.
“campaigns and ad sets that are already running, so the platforms aren't learning from scratch”
Andrew Faris suggests adding a separate campaign for sale ads with pre-scheduled launch dates, to manage different budgets and bid controls.
“take your sale ads, pre scheduled the launch dates of them”
Andrew Faris's sale playbook: launch with a loose cost cap under a hard budget ceiling; once on target, raise budget 50% and cut the cap 20%; the day after, cut the cap about 50%. The numbers are illustrative.
Andrew Faris says that for short sales or ad sets with low conversion volume, you might consider auto bidding instead of manual bidding.
“you might consider, despite what I said at number one, actually auto bidding your sale ads, auto bidding your sale period.”
Meta says to start holiday campaigns as early as possible so learning finishes before the peak, and that more creative formats give Advantage+ more ways to match ads to people. It gives no lead time data.
“should begin their campaigns as early as possible”
Common Thread Collective runs two campaign types: always-on evergreen campaigns split between acquisition and retention, and time-bound campaigns for sales and launches with set start and end dates.
“Marketing moment campaigns are time-bound, attached to sales, product launches, or any other event”
CTC splits accounts into evergreen campaigns (acquisition and retention) and marketing moment campaigns. Anything time-bound, such as a sale or product launch, goes in a marketing moment campaign.
“Anything that is time-bound starts here, ends here, goes in marketing moment.”
Flighted says brands past $100K a month should run promotions in their own campaign, live during sale windows and paused between events, because promo spikes skew learning in the core campaigns.
“Keep this campaign separate, run it during promotional windows, and pause it between events”
CTC's Joy Sharma tests a new offer in a marketing moment campaign against set order value and CAC targets, not in evergreen, and moves it to evergreen only if it wins. CTC sells this service.
“I'm fine running it in the marketing moment and if it wins, I'll graduate into evergreen.”
Jon Loomer tried Meta's Push Delivery to This Ad, which sends a share of budget to a chosen ad for 1 to 30 days. He pushed 10% to five ads with no performance results yet, and warns habitual use could raise costs.
“running fine and dividing my budget as expected”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer