Should we send birthday and anniversary emails?
Our answer
Yes. Once core flows run, add a yearly birthday series of two or three emails with a real offer, around 15 to 20% off or a gift, and a month to redeem it.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 official rules
- 1 dataset, 3 practitioners, 1 opinion or claim
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 8 statements
- K
OLTMT
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentBirthday messages bring large orders. Omnisend's 2025 data across 150,000 brands found they averaged $744.37 an order, more than 4 times its average. That is revenue Omnisend attributes to its own automations.
Many brands that ask for a birthday never send the email. Guy Hanson of Litmus counted only 43 of 124 expected emails arriving. Those that came averaged an 18% discount, and the best ran an advance notice, a birthday message and a reminder.
It is a small, later addition. Threadpoint (Klaviyo email agency) builds birthday flows as 2 or 3 emails once a list reaches 10K to 50K subscribers, and Mailercloud (email software maker) expects them to bring 1 to 3% of email revenue.
Our judgment
- Build the birthday flow after the core flows in The first automated flows to build, not first. Mailercloud expects it to bring a small share of email revenue, and Threadpoint layers it in only once a list passes its foundation stage.
- Make the offer around 15 to 20% off or a gift of similar value, sized to your margin. That is the middle of the cited examples, from Gymshark's 15% and Magnolia's 25% in Shopify's examples to the 18% average across Hanson's inbox and Mailercloud's 20%.
- Send two or three emails around a redemption window of about a month. That combines Hanson's series and 30 day windows, Threadpoint's teaser, birthday and last-chance emails, Klaviyo's email a week ahead and Gymshark's month to redeem.
- Use the anniversary of the first order when you have no birthdays. Mailercloud uses that trigger, and Klaviyo offers pre-built anniversary flows.
Our judgment, built from Mailercloud, Threadpoint, Shopify, Litmus and Klaviyo: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
8 statements from 7 sourcesToast, which sells restaurant loyalty software, says guests must join the loyalty program to get a birthday reward, usable once, in store only, in a window around the birthday.
“Birthday rewards may only be redeemed in-store.”
Klaviyo says birthday flows need birthdays stored on profiles, should send early in the day in local time and repeat yearly; starting a week early helps when the offer is used in person.
“Setting the flow to start before a birthday is useful when you're providing an in-person offer or discount, as it gives them time to plan when they want to use it.”
Klaviyo says date-triggered flows such as birthdays need dates in an accepted format, and a birthday flow can start sending up to two weeks before the date.
“a birthday flow can start sending messages to a recipient two weeks before their actual birthday.”
A Validity executive who gives his birthday whenever asked got only 43 of 124 expected birthday emails (35%), with an average discount of 18%. He suggests a before, on-the-day and reminder series.
“Don't collect data you won't use.”
Threadpoint, a Klaviyo agency, suggests a 2 to 3 email birthday flow once a list passes 10K subscribers, saying birthday emails get high open rates because they feel personal. It gives no figures.
“Collect birth dates (even just the month) and send a birthday email with a small gift or offer.”
Shopify's blog lists birthday rewards such as Gymshark's 15% off for a month and Magnolia's 25% off, says no one reward type is best, and says to store birth dates securely and explain why you ask.
“There isn't a single best reward type; efficacy varies from business to business.”
Mailercloud, which sells email software, estimates birthday flows bring 1 to 3% of email revenue but often 55 to 70% open rates, and urges a meaningful offer. Its figures have no stated source.
“a stingy birthday offer does more brand damage than no email at all.”
Omnisend's 2026 report on its own customers says birthday messages had average order values more than 4x the norm ($744.37), and abandoned cart and welcome messages drove 76% of automated orders.
“Abandoned cart and Welcome messages drove 76% of all automation-generated orders”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer