Which checkout changes raise conversion the most: accelerated wallets like Shop Pay and Apple Pay, fewer fields, or guest checkout?
Our answer
Make guest checkout the default and offer wallets such as Shop Pay, Apple Pay and PayPal above the card form and in the cart. Show full costs before checkout, then remove fields you don't need.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 2 official rules, 1 dataset, 5 practitioners
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 9 statements
BIBCCCGDN
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentShoppers leave over surprise costs more than anything else. Among US shoppers, 39% left over unexpected extra charges, 19% over forced account creation, 18% over a long or complex checkout and 10% over a missing payment method (Baymard Institute, ecommerce UX research firm).
Wallet buttons in the cart lift conversion. In a review of 13 tests, each one that put wallets in the cart or cart drawer moved conversion up, though one store's order value fell 17% (Blend Commerce, Shopify CRO agency).
Shop Pay's store-wide lift is modest. In Shopify's own Princess Polly case, conversion rose 4.1% for shoppers with a Shop Pay session and 1 to 1.6% store wide (reported by Clean Commit, Shopify development agency).
Our judgment
We put guest checkout and wallets before field cuts. Baymard counts forced account creation and a missing payment method among the reasons shoppers leave, wallet buttons carry the most test results in Blend Commerce's review, both are settings on Shopify and Shopify lets merchants change only some checkout fields. Show full costs before checkout ahead of any of the three, since unexpected extra charges are the most cited reason in Baymard's survey. Judge a wallet change on revenue per visitor and order value as well as conversion, since Blend Commerce saw order value fall in one cart test and Clean Commit finds Shop Pay's store-wide lift far smaller than its lift for shoppers with a Shop Pay session.
Our judgment, built from Baymard Institute, Blend Commerce, Shopify and Clean Commit: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
9 statements from 6 sourcesShopify lets merchants set some checkout fields as required, optional or hidden. Requiring sign-in hides Apple Pay and other accelerated checkout options in the cart.
“accelerated checkout options such as Apple Pay aren't displayed in the online store cart to prevent any checkouts from bypassing the sign-in requirement”
Shopify says accelerated checkout buttons let customers skip the cart and pay from the product page with saved details, and warns that hiding them might hurt conversion rates. Shopify sells Shop Pay.
“Be aware that hiding your accelerated checkout options might have a negative impact on your conversion rates.”
A newsletter relays that Shopify now shows payment methods as tiles instead of a list on eligible checkouts. It says nobody knows yet whether this gets more people through checkout, and gives no data.
“Whether it gets more people through checkout? Nobody knows yet.”
Shopify says Shop Pay lifts conversion up to 50% over guest checkout, from a study it commissioned, with no sample or method shown, and lists checkout checks such as showing costs early.
“Shop Pay lifts conversion by up to 50% relative to guest checkout and completes checkout up to four times faster”
Blend Commerce reviewed 13 of its clients' A/B tests on Shopify: express checkout in the cart lifted conversion in every test, while on product pages both adding and removing it won in different stores.
“Every cart or cart-drawer test in this review moved conversion positively, although the Plant Brand result was directional.”
Clean Commit, which sells Shopify development, says Shopify's claim that Shop Pay lifts conversion up to 50% has no published method. Shopify's own Princess Polly test showed 4.1% for Shop Pay users, 1 to 1.6% storewide.
“Conversion went up 4.1% for shoppers who already had a Shop Pay session, and closer to 1 to 1.6% store wide.”
Glued, a checkout agency, says forcing account creation cuts checkout completion 20 to 35% for new visitors across its clients, and puts guest checkout first. No dataset published.
“Make guest checkout the first and most prominent option.”
Baymard says 12% of US shoppers abandoned an order for not seeing the total cost upfront. It advises picking payment in a dedicated checkout section, preselecting card, and wallet buttons above the card form.
“Third-party payment options such as Apple Pay, Google Pay, and PayPal should appear as distinct, clearly labeled buttons above the card form.”
Baymard puts average cart abandonment at 70.22%. Of US shoppers who left, 39% cited unexpected extra costs and 19% forced account creation, so it recommends guest checkout as the default.
“Prioritize guest checkout as the default path, deferring registration until after the order is confirmed.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer