Should AppLovin be a prospecting channel, a retargeting channel or both?
Our answer
Treat AppLovin as a prospecting channel. Pick Universal, Prospecting or Discovery by your goal, connect your order history and skip a separate retargeting campaign. Add a small Universal or Prospecting campaign at about 10% of spend once new-customer results hold.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 2 controlled tests
- 3 AppLovin rules, 3 datasets, 2 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 13 statements
- A
HS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
4 reasons and our judgmentAppLovin gives you no audience lists to retarget with. Its help pages offer three audience strategies instead, and Jetfuel Agency (consumer marketing agency) notes existing customers can't be excluded. Advertisers choose between Discovery and Prospecting and little else, says Will Frank of AS Beauty (AdExchanger).
Most of what it drives is new customers. Haus measured about 66.3% of AppLovin's impact on own-site sales coming from new customers, and HexClad's holdouts showed 90% new customers.
AppLovin prospecting worked at multiple brands, not just one. Measured, an incrementality testing firm, found AppLovin prospecting incremental at multiple brands, not just retargeting.
The new-customer campaign types test well. Common Thread Collective (CTC) found its Discovery tests averaged 284% incrementality, and it layers about 10% of spend into Universal or Prospecting on top. Jetfuel Agency instead starts accounts on Universal and tests Prospecting later.
Our judgment
- A retargeting buy has little to work with on AppLovin. It offers no audience lists or exclusions, and the tests that split results found mostly new customers, so we treat it as a prospecting channel.
- Pick the audience strategy by your goal. Choose Universal at launch or when total return is the goal, and Prospecting or Discovery when you are judged on new customers. This combines AppLovin's description of each strategy with Jetfuel Agency's launch practice and CTC's Discovery results.
- Reach past visitors with a small add-on campaign. Run a small Universal or Prospecting campaign beside a working new-customer campaign rather than a dedicated retargeting campaign, applying CTC's layer of about 10% of spend. That fits the small retargeting share A dedicated retargeting campaign sets on Meta.
- Judge each AppLovin campaign on new-customer results and a holdout test. Measured says platform attribution over-credits retargeting most.
Our judgment, built from AppLovin, Jetfuel, Will Frank (AS Beauty), Haus, Measured, HexClad and Common Thread Collective: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
13 statements from 8 sourcesAppLovin purchase campaigns can target all buyers (Universal), new customers only (Prospecting) or people new to your site (Discovery), and the last two need Shopify or uploaded purchase history.
“Prospecting campaigns optimize new customer acquisition only.”
AppLovin says Universal optimizes for all purchases or revenue, Prospecting for new customers only. You can run both at once, and Prospecting works best with purchase history from Shopify or Events Manager.
“You can run both simultaneously if you want to balance total purchases against new-customer growth across different cohorts.”
AppLovin highly recommends sharing order history to optimize prospecting, either through its Shopify app or a CSV upload, subject to your own privacy notices and consents.
“To optimize prospecting campaigns (which acquire new customers), AppLovin highly recommends that you provide AppLovin with order history data.”
AppLovin says in BFCM 2025 new-customer checkouts hit 3.3x the normal baseline versus 2.9x for returning customers, and suggests separate new-customer campaigns started a week or two early. Its own data.
“Avoid cutting or reallocating their budget based on the first few days”
Sprites, an AI ad tool seller, relays a Jefferies survey of 30 advertisers: they put 11.1% of budgets on AppLovin in Q2 2026, and 73% said prospecting there raised new-customer revenue. Views, not a test.
“73% said prospecting there increased revenue from new customers.”
Measured's panel put commerce retargeting DSPs, including AppLovin at 2.0x, at 1.9x its benchmark, but results were bimodal: one DSP indexed above 4x at one brand and near zero at another.
“Retargeting-heavy programs need incrementality validation more than any other buy, because platform attribution over-credits most here.”
HexClad's Connor Rolain says AppLovin reaches the most new customers for HexClad: holdouts plus Northbeam showed 90% new customers, 36% higher ROAS and 27% lower CAC. The post carries an AppLovin credit offer.
“Which channel will help me reach the most new customers?”
AdExchanger quotes AS Beauty's Will Frank saying setting up an AppLovin campaign is straightforward: no audience controls or keyword strategy, just a choice between Discovery and Prospecting.
“no audience controls, no keyword strategies”
Haus, which sells incrementality tests, found new customers made up about 66.3% of AppLovin's measured impact on brands' own-site sales, similar to other channels, in tests from January 2025 to March 2026.
“AppLovin had a higher new-customer share than the brand's tested channel median 51% of the time.”
Jetfuel, an agency, says launch AppLovin on the Universal audience and notes existing customers can't be excluded at audience level. It relays a Haus test where AppLovin served mostly existing customers.
“there are no campaign-level audience exclusions at all; the only exclusion lever available is creative-level”
CTC, which sells AppLovin management, says AppLovin Discovery goes after nearly 100% new users, while older universal campaigns mix prospecting and retargeting. It mostly runs Discovery with about 10% universal.
“Discovery is in an effort from AppLovin to go after like 100% new users”
CTC's Connor McLaughlin says the agency runs separate prospecting, retention and remarketing campaigns on Meta, and on AppLovin adds about 10% of spend in a prospecting campaign. No Meta data.
“on Google we have brand non-brand, meta we have prospecting, retention, remarketing”
CTC's Connor McLaughlin says AppLovin results vary widely, so each brand should run its own test, suggesting $5K of spend plus $5K of AppLovin credit. CTC is an AppLovin partner and offers a $5K spend match.
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer