How should we handle Amazon's own brands competing with ours?
Our answer
Win on a real product difference, a stronger listing, and reviews and brand searches you build off Amazon. Defend your brand terms with ads. Keep sales growing off Amazon.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 practitioners
- Sources
- 4 sources
- 4 statements
- WGNMA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentPrice alone is rarely a lasting answer. Amazon's brands compete on price, selection and visibility (Witz Group, an Amazon marketplace partner, and AllyHub, an Amazon research software maker).
Amazon's brands can only hurt you on Amazon, not on your site or other channels (Netpeak, a digital marketing agency). Netpeak also says Amazon launches its version 15 to 25% below the category, often with Prime placement.
Some categories are best avoided. Marknology, an Amazon agency, tells clients to stay out of batteries, basic electronics accessories and household staples, where Amazon Basics wins on price and trust.
Our judgment
Witz Group, Netpeak, Marknology and AllyHub agree on product difference, listing quality, reviews and brand demand over price, and we take that as the plan. We add ad defense of your brand terms and product pages, from Witz Group's rating of Sponsored Brands on brand terms and defensive product targeting as critical, and Netpeak's warning against going dark on ads when a private label rival arrives. We also add sales growth off Amazon, since Witz Group says brands relying only on Amazon traffic are more exposed.
Our judgment, built from Witz Group, Netpeak, Marknology and AllyHub: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
4 statements from 4 sourcesMarknology, an Amazon agency, tells private label sellers to avoid categories Amazon's own brands dominate, such as batteries, and to differentiate rather than compete on price.
“Amazon Basics competes here directly and wins on price and trust.”
Witz Group, an Amazon brand partner, says Amazon's own and independent private labels undercut brands, and suggests auditing titles, reviews, branded and defensive ads, and traffic from outside Amazon.
“Brands that rely solely on Amazon traffic are generally more vulnerable to private label competition.”
AllyHub, which sells Amazon research software, says to beat Amazon Basics by differentiating, be cautious where Amazon's own brands are strong, and look for categories they have not entered or entered poorly.
“Be cautious in categories where Amazon Basics or other Amazon private label brands already have strong visibility.”
Netpeak, which sells marketplace ads, says Amazon's own brands launch 15 to 25% cheaper on high-demand products, and urges brands to differentiate, keep advertising and spread sales beyond Amazon.
“Treat Amazon like your largest wholesale account: important, profitable, but never your only one.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer