How should we decide when a price is too low?
Our answer
Call a price too low when a test shows a price about 5 to 10% higher earns more profit per visitor. Check ad cost per purchase and repeat buying before you keep it.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 1 dataset, 9 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 12 sources
- 15 statements
CM
CSB
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentIn a test, a deep price cut barely moved profit, and a price rise moved it more. Convertibles (Shopify conversion agency) tested halving two $99 products, which lifted profit per visitor only from $0.44 to $0.50. Raising one product to $125 lifted it to $0.68.
Modest price rises often leave conversion where it was. Shoplift (Shopify A/B testing app) reports that Minnow's 10% increase and SAXX's 5% increase left conversion unchanged. Intelligems advises that a flat result on a higher price can be permission to raise it.
A price rise can pay even when orders fall. A premium home goods brand raised prices 25%, lost 21.5% of order volume and grew contribution margin 54% (Common Thread Collective).
Our judgment
Treat warning signs as reasons to test a higher price rather than proof, because Intelligems and Shoplift both decide on a test and Convertibles' test found both a floor and a ceiling. Keep a higher price only after checking ad cost per purchase and repeat buying. Juan Cruz (MarsMen) dropped an on-site winner that lowered conversion when its Meta cost per purchase rose, and The Andrew Faris Podcast describes repurchase falling after a category price rise. A price cut is not the default fix for slow sales, since Convertibles' half-price variant barely lifted profit per visitor and Omnia Retail (dynamic pricing software maker) argues lower prices can make buyers doubt quality.
Our judgment, built from Intelligems, Shoplift, Convertibles, Juan Cruz (MarsMen), The Andrew Faris Podcast and Omnia Retail: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 12 sourcesRidge's Connor MacDonald says gradual price rises grew value faster than conversion fell, though some rises cut revenue per session; a 15% price cut on pens raised pen revenue 60%.
“you can drop prices 15% like we did with pens”
Connor MacDonald says that between price points like $100 and $150 he would almost pick the lower one, because the extra volume gives Meta's algorithm more signal.
“I'll almost take the 100 so that I can drive more volume so that we have more signal. We have a larger TAM.”
Cody Plofker says Jones Road cut its free shipping threshold from $85 to $55 after raising order value to about $110, going too high and too low. Winks launched at $86 and needed lower prices to get signal.
“we went too high and too low”
Last Crumb's founder says it priced its cookie box as the high end of the market because the middle just fights for share. It tested prices from 110 and settled at $140, adding value to justify it.
“we were testing different price points and we ended up laying at 140”
MarsMen's ecommerce head says a test that raised revenue per visitor about 25% on site (higher AOV, lower conversion) lifted Meta CPA 50%, so it was not rolled out. He suspects Meta charges more when conversion falls.
“we ended up seeing an increase in CPA of 50% and then the ROAS stopped making sense”
Shopify's guide sets target price as unit cost divided by one minus the desired margin, checked against competitor prices; it warns competitor-based pricing can become a race to the bottom. No data.
“At a minimum, your price should let you break even on each sale.”
On Andrew Faris's podcast, the speakers say most brands pick prices irrationally and suggest big price tests that narrow over time; one company raised prices 20% with no drag by charging for things it gave free.
“one of the things that is most irrationally chosen in e-commerce like people just sort of pick a number”
Intelligems, which sells price testing software, says to test the current price against prices 5 to 10% lower and higher at once for two to three weeks, judging on profit per visitor.
“Based on data from thousands of price tests, a 5% price change typically moves conversion rate by around 10% in the opposite direction.”
Booper, a pricing software vendor, says measure price elasticity excluding promotions and stockouts, ideally against control stores or with A/B tests. A single price change or a two-week read is not reliable.
“Elasticity calculated based on a single price change is merely anecdotal, not a meaningful measure.”
Common Thread Collective, an agency, says brands that raised prices for tariffs should not roll back sitewide. Check competitor prices and first-purchase AOV, and compare repeat rates of customers won before and after.
“If your first-purchase AOV is now above market comparables for your category, you're pricing out the top of the funnel.”
Shoplift, which sells price testing, reports customer tests: Minnow raised swimwear prices 10% with normal conversion, and SAXX's 5% increase showed no significant conversion difference. No sample sizes.
“cost-based pricing ignores the only number that matters: what customers will actually pay.”
In one Convertibles price test for a wellness brand, halving two $99 prices barely moved profit per visitor ($0.44 to $0.50), while pricing them at $125 and $90 lifted it to $0.68 (sample not stated).
“Price is a quality signal, especially in categories where customers can't easily compare products.”
Omnia Retail, which sells pricing software, warns against copying competitors' prices, saying it starts price wars and lower prices can signal lower quality. No data.
“Many businesses make the mistake of simply copying their competitors' prices.”
Intelligems says data from over 1,000 price tests shows a 5% price change typically moves conversion about 10%, so whether a price change raises profit depends on margins.
“price changes create roughly 2x the conversion impact (a 5% price change typically drives a 10% conversion change)”
Intelligems, which sells price testing software, suggests testing launch prices from day one in three groups (full, 10-15% premium, 10-15% discount), judged on profit per visitor, since early adopters often pay more.
“Early adopters often pay more, not less.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- What the research saysWhat academic research adds, kept apart from the answer
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer