How should we track rankings now that results vary by user and AI features?
Our answer
Track rankings as trends, not one true position. Use Search Console for where you actually appeared and a fixed-setting rank tracker for competitors and page features, read weekly by keyword group. Use repeated checks for AI answers.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 7 official rules
- 2 datasets, 5 practitioners
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 14 statements
- GBASSBTGKIG
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentNo single position exists to track. Results vary between people by location, language, device and search history. Search Console's average position averages every impression, so your own search can differ from it (Google).
AI answers change between identical searches. The same local prompt overlapped only 20 to 33% between runs (BrightLocal, local SEO software maker). Prompt tracking should work like polling (Kevin Indig, organic growth newsletter and advisor).
A tracker is only useful with its settings held still. Blck Alpaca (Austrian SEO agency) and SearchCounselCo (SEO consultancy) fix location, language and device for each tracked series. Blck Alpaca treats daily swings of 2 to 5 positions as normal.
Our judgment
Use Search Console as the main source on where you appeared, within the limits in Using Search Console data, and a rank tracker for competitors and page features. Google says third-party tools lack its ranking data, and Blck Alpaca says the two answer different questions. Treat presence in AI Overviews and AI answers as a rate over repeated checks. That applies the repeat-run variation BrightLocal measured on local prompts and The GEO Lab saw on one page, with Kevin Indig's view that prompt tracking is closer to polling. For a local business, a grid of points across the service area replaces a single tracked point. BrightLocal and GetRankOnMap, a Google Maps rank tracker, both found results change as the searcher moves, and SearchCounselCo says one city-level observation cannot represent every neighborhood.
Our judgment, built from Google, Blck Alpaca, BrightLocal, The GEO Lab, Kevin Indig, GetRankOnMap and SearchCounselCo: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
14 statements from 8 sourcesGoogle says search results differ between people because of language, location and device as well as personalization, and some information like location is used even with personalization turned off.
“Search results may vary between people for reasons other than personalization, such as language settings or localized results.”
Google says it ranks results using query words, page relevance and usability, source expertise, and the searcher's location, history and settings.
“we use information such as your location, past Search history, and Search settings to determine what is most relevant for you in the moment.”
Search Console averages position across all impressions. Every link in an AI Overview gets that Overview's single position, and AI Mode follows the same method as regular results.
“An AI Overview occupies a single position in search results, and all links in the AI Overview are assigned that same position.”
Google advises watching trends in impressions and clicks more than average position, and checking that Search gains line up in time with your site changes, compared with similar past periods.
“In general, it's recommended to focus more on trends in impressions and clicks than on position alone.”
Blck Alpaca, an SEO agency, says Search Console's average position and a rank tracker's position answer different questions, so use both; weekly tracking suits most sites, as positions move 2 to 5 places daily.
“A GSC average position of 8.4 and a tracker position of 4 for the same keyword are both correct; they simply answer different questions.”
SearchCounselCo, an SEO consultancy, says to track rankings with a fixed engine, location, language and device, keep mobile and desktop separate, and not treat a manual search as a universal rank.
“A manual search is a dated visual observation, not a universal rank.”
BrightLocal, which sells local rank tracking, ran 200,085 local AI searches: repeat searches overlapped only 21 to 33%, and Google Maps named a tracked business in 66% of searches against 32 to 38% for AI.
“We'd recommend tracking both Google Maps rankings and local AI visibility”
GetRankOnMap, which sells a grid rank tracker, found in three Indian cities that businesses appeared in 96.4% of map searches within 500 metres but 11.1% at one to two kilometres. One snapshot.
“Distance decides whether you appear. Reviews decide the order.”
Running one query on his own page 10 times in an afternoon, Artur Ferreira saw Google's AI Overview cite it in 6 of 9 renders, so one check proves nothing. One page, one query, one day.
“a single check of an AI Overview citation, by you or by a tool, is not evidence of presence or absence, so any visibility claim needs at least five renders across two or more configurations”
Kevin Indig says 91% of AI search citations appear in only one of ChatGPT, Perplexity or AI Overviews, so tracking should work like polling a panel of prompts, not like Google rank tracking.
“Prompt tracking should be closer to polling and focus groups than SEO rank tracking.”
A Semrush site's SEO reporting guide tracks topical visibility over small ranking shifts, puts AI Overview citations and AI referral traffic beside organic search, and ties results to business outcomes.
“Organic traffic that doesn't produce business results is, in the end, a vanity metric.”
Google says good SEO advice cites data, experience or official guidance, that it does not evaluate third-party services, and that outside tools cannot see its ranking data or guarantee results.
“Third-party tools don't have access to our internal ranking data. They can't guarantee performance.”
Search Console now reports impressions in Google's generative AI features, such as AI Overviews and AI Mode, by page, country, device and date, rolled out to all sites by August 31, 2026.
“As of August 31, 2026, we've rolled out these insights to all websites worldwide.”
Google's May 2026 update extends Personal Intelligence in AI Mode to nearly 200 countries, letting users opt in to connect Gmail and Photos, and lets users follow up from AI Overviews into AI Mode.
“you choose if and when you want to connect apps like Gmail and Google Photos.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer