Should we sell wholesale through Shopify, and how should it be kept apart from retail?
Our answer
Sell wholesale only if a price about half of retail still leaves margin after trade costs. Run it in your Shopify store with built-in B2B and prices behind buyer login. Use a separate store only for separate stock or teams.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 2 official rules
- 3 practitioners, 5 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 10 statements
ECEADRR
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentShopify's built-in B2B covers most needs on any plan from Basic up. Companies, net terms and quantity rules come on Basic, Grow, Advanced and Plus, but below Plus you get only 3 active catalogs (Shopify).
Wholesale cuts margin hard. At keystone pricing a $60 item sells to a store for $30, which takes a 70% margin to about 40% (Taylor Sicard, consumer growth consultant). Chargebacks of 1 to 5% and net 30 to 90 terms come on top.
Choosing between one shared retail and wholesale store and a dedicated B2B store is hard to undo. Switching between a blended and a dedicated store later means redoing most setup, and a blended store's inventory is shared and can't be allocated by customer type (Shopify).
Our judgment
- Start with retail and wholesale in one blended store. Move to a dedicated store only for separate stock, a trade-only store, a separate buying experience or a separate team. Shopify says a blended store fits when you sell similar products and share inventory and staff, and AD Digitech and Ringly treat one store as the default.
- Price wholesale before saying yes to a retailer. Count chargebacks, trade spend and net terms on top of the keystone cut. Eightx (fractional CFO firm) finds beauty wholesale lands near 25 to 30% contribution because it carries no customer acquisition cost.
- Stay on Basic, Grow or Advanced while your price tiers fit 3 catalogs. Count price levels times pricing regions plus contract accounts, as Elogic Commerce does. Move to Plus when that count passes 3 or you need deposits or partial payments.
- Keep your own site from undercutting retailers. Hold one retail price across channels and keep some products wholesale-only, as RepSpark advises.
Our judgment, built from Shopify, AD Digitech, Ringly, Taylor Sicard, Eightx, Elogic Commerce and RepSpark: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 9 sourcesShopify says a blended store runs B2B and D2C in one admin with shared inventory, discounts and shipping by default, while a dedicated store separates them. Switching later means redoing most of the setup.
“You need to make this decision carefully, as it's not easy to change at a later time.”
Shopify B2B runs on Basic, Grow, Advanced and Plus, not Starter or Retail. Non-Plus plans get up to 3 active B2B catalogs; Plus gets unlimited catalogs, deposits and partial payments.
“Most B2B features are available on all plans, including companies, catalogs, net payment terms, self-serve ordering, and Shopify Flow automations.”
Ringly, which sells AI phone support, says non-Plus Shopify stores can run B2B and DTC in one store, but the 3-catalog cap bites; show MSRP publicly, and below $5M wholesale you likely don't need Plus.
“The 3-catalog cap on non-Plus plans is real and you will hit it.”
eSEOspace, a Shopify developer, says a blended B2B store keeps one catalog and admin for overlapping products, while a dedicated wholesale store needs a second plan unless you are on Plus.
“Place a test order as a test buyer before inviting real customers.”
Elogic Commerce, which builds Shopify Plus stores, says count your B2B catalogs (price levels times regions plus contract accounts) and if you need more than 3, you need Plus. Decide blended or separate stores early.
“If the result is more than 3, you need Shopify Plus.”
AD Digitech, which builds Shopify B2B stores, says a brand with 20 to 40 wholesale customers on fixed tiers and net-30 terms can run B2B on Advanced, moving to Plus at about 500 customers.
“Wholesale buyers see B2B pricing and payment options after they log in; retail shoppers see your normal storefront.”
RepSpark, which sells wholesale ordering software, says DTC prices should not undercut retailers' margins, channels should get some distinct products, and inventory should be allocated on purpose.
“Your DTC pricing should not undercut the retail price your wholesale partners need to make their margin.”
Taylor Sicard, a margin consultant, says keystone wholesale pricing cuts a 70% DTC gross margin to about 40%, and payment terms, chargebacks and trade spend can push it to single digits.
“Use Faire to find accounts, use Shopify B2B to own them.”
Eightx, a finance firm, models that beauty brands net about 30% contribution DTC and 25 to 30% wholesale to Sephora or Ulta. The real differences are cash cycle and customer data, not margin.
“The real differences are cash cycle and data, not headline margin: wholesale ties up receivables for 60 to 90 days and hands the customer to the retailer.”
Ridge's CEO advises keeping it simple at first (Shopify, Amazon, one wholesale account, one or two 3PL warehouses) and not going international at the start; Ridge itself did too much early.
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer