Should we run SMS, and through which platform?
Our answer
Add SMS once email flows work and orders are steady. Start with automated texts before broadcasts and run it in your email platform unless SMS is its own channel. Judge it on margin after message fees.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 8 official rules
- 3 datasets, 3 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 17 statements
- PK
O
MBCEM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAutomated texts earn far more per send than broadcasts. SMS flows were 7.6% of sends but 45.2% of SMS revenue across more than 183,000 Klaviyo customers. Omnisend's automated texts earned $0.74 per send against $0.15 for campaigns.
Your email platform is the default home for SMS. A brand on Klaviyo email should use Klaviyo SMS (BS&Co). SMS-first tools like Postscript suit brands that run SMS as its own channel (Eightx, Evolve Media).
Small stores should stay with email, and every text costs money. Mastroke keeps email first below about 30 orders a month. Shopify Messaging charges $0.012 per US text plus $2.15 a month per toll-free number.
Our judgment
We put SMS after working email flows and automated texts before broadcasts, going by Klaviyo's and Omnisend's flow results and Mastroke's and Eightx's advice to build abandoned cart and welcome flows first. We keep SMS in the platform that sends your email unless SMS runs as its own channel. BS&Co argues per-credit prices are close across platforms, Eightx and Evolve Media place SMS-first tools with brands that run SMS separately or at larger size, and Evolve Media says running SMS on several platforms rarely works. We judge SMS on margin after message fees rather than credited revenue. That combines Mastroke's advice to count message fees, discounts and order margin, BS&Co's monthly check of SMS spend against attributed revenue, Jordan Gordon's comparison of SMS cost per click with ad cost per click and Eightx's warning that last-click credit can overstate SMS.
Our judgment, built from Klaviyo, Omnisend, Mastroke, Eightx, BS&Co, Evolve Media and DTC Podcast: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
17 statements from 10 sourcesPostscript's pricing page: SMS costs $0.009 on Starter, falling to $0.007 on the $500 plan, plus carrier fees near $0.0033. Short codes cost $750 a month; messages over 160 characters bill per segment.
“Messages over 160 characters 'are split into multiple message segments, each of which is charged at the per-SMS rate.'”
Shopify Messaging charges per SMS marketing message: $0.012 in the US, $0.025 in Canada and $0.06 in the UK, plus $2.15 a month per US or Canadian toll-free number. SMS to Spain and Austria is paused.
“A $2.15 USD monthly charge applies to each approved toll-free number used for SMS marketing in the United States and Canada.”
Omnisend's Shopify listing shows a free plan for 250 contacts and 500 emails a month, Standard from $16 a month for 500 contacts, and Pro from $59 a month for 2,500 contacts with unlimited emails and SMS.
“Starting price covers up to 500 contacts and rises as your list grows.”
Klaviyo's per-message SMS rates include carrier fees, with no separate carrier fee charges. Its billing page lists no US per-message rate. Flex is offered on self-service plans from $490 a month list.
“Carrier fees stay included in your rate, so there are no separate carrier fee line items to account for.”
Klaviyo's SMS benchmarks from over 183,000 customers: flows are 7.6% of SMS sends but 45.2% of SMS revenue, and it expects order rates of 0.27% for campaigns and 1.9% for flows, by its own attribution.
“Ecommerce brands should expect SMS conversion rates, or order rates, of 0.27% for campaigns and 1.9% for flows.”
Postscript, an SMS platform, says it launched email that shares one customer profile with SMS, with four attribution models and migration of existing flows and templates. Rollout is first come, first served.
“Postscript customers running SMS can add email without changes to their existing program; the two channels share a single customer profile and context layer.”
Mastroke, which sells email and SMS management, says SMS is not needed on day one: under 30 orders a month focus on email, start with abandoned cart, then add SMS. It also says no order threshold fits every store.
“If you're getting fewer than 30 orders per month, email should still be the primary focus.”
Bandwidth, a messaging provider, lists AT&T surcharges rising April 1, 2026: SMS from $0.0030 to $0.0035 per message, MMS from $0.0075 to $0.0090, plus new inbound short code fees.
“No action is needed. These surcharges will be automatically applied to your Bandwidth invoice starting April 1, 2026.”
Klaviyo moved SMS from credits to per-message dollar rates on July 13, 2026 for new and free accounts, and for paid plans at the first billing date after August 13, 2026, with US short code and toll-free priced apart.
“Depending on your channel mix and sending regions, your rates may increase or decrease.”
Eightx, a finance firm for consumer brands, says Postscript suits SMS-first Shopify brands under about $20M, Attentive suits those above $20M, and Klaviyo SMS wins if you want one data model for email and SMS.
“Brands that want one data model for email and SMS are usually better served keeping both inside Klaviyo.”
Evolve Media's founder claims SMS returns $20 to $30 ROAS for ecommerce brands without a method, and matches tools to size: Postscript for $1M to $50M Shopify brands, Attentive above $50K SMS spend.
“Multi-platform SMS rarely works.”
Jordan Gordon says to treat SMS like a paid acquisition channel by working out its cost per click and comparing it with your advertising cost per click.
“treat it like a paid channel and establish a cost per click”
Eightx, a CFO firm, estimates from vendor data that SMS brings 10 to 20% of revenue for mature programs and 5 to 10% for early ones, and says a low share usually means missing automated flows.
“If your SMS is under 8% of revenue and flows are under 30% of SMS revenue, the gap is automation coverage.”
BS&Co, which manages Klaviyo SMS, says brands already on Klaviyo email should use it for SMS too, since the savings come from one platform. Its popup for email subscribers converted 5.09% across four client brands.
“There's almost no scenario where a dedicated SMS platform makes sense if Klaviyo is your email provider.”
From January 1, 2026, Postscript bills undelivered texts (typically 2 to 4% of send volume, once credited back) and inbound replies and opt-ins at the standard message rate.
“Undelivered messages will no longer be credited back at the end of each billing cycle.”
Postscript's data on over 17,000 Shopify stores calls over $2 revenue per SMS message strong and over $4 highly optimized; median acquisition is about 1.06% of new orders and most send 2 a month.
“Most brands send about 2 messages per month per subscriber.”
Omnisend, which sells SMS, says across 2025 sends on its platform automated SMS earned $0.74 per send against $0.15 for campaigns. It flags that an OS update inflated SMS clicks with likely bot activity.
“Automated SMS messages earned an average of $0.74 per send”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer