Should we use retail media TV ads, such as Walmart's, that tie viewing to purchases?
Our answer
Use a retailer's TV ads only for products it already sells in volume, after its on-site search ads work. Judge them on a holdout test, since the retailer's report counts only its own sales.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 official rules
- 1 dataset, 4 practitioners, 7 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 11 sources
- 15 statements
- WB
ACM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentRetailer TV comes after on-site search ads. Bigeye (paid media agency) buys off-site inventory only once efficient on-site placements run out, and plans Walmart Connect only when Walmart is a top-three customer. AMZDudes adds Amazon's streaming TV only after its sponsored ads run consistently.
Retailer reports can't show what the ads added. Walmart's offsite reports tie impressions to verified Walmart transactions online, and Measured calls Amazon's attribution Amazon-centric. The closed loop shows who bought after an ad, not who would have bought anyway (Ad Measurement Weekly).
Retail data costs extra. Bigeye says the off-site price includes a data markup and weaker measurement than on-site search. It buys the same streaming inventory directly unless the retailer's version wins more new buyers per dollar in a lift test.
Our judgment
Use a retailer's TV ads only for products that retailer already sells in volume and after its on-site search ads run well, following Bigeye and AMZDudes, with Canopy Management's advice to leave connected TV alone unless you can measure it. Judge it on a holdout or sales lift test rather than the retailer's report, because the report credits only sales the retailer sees, and Measured calls Amazon's attribution Amazon-centric. Ad Measurement Weekly treats closed-loop data as a signal, not ground truth, and OneElevate holds it to independent incrementality. A brand selling mainly through its own site should test the retailer's shopper audiences against a direct streaming buy. That applies Bigeye's rule to buy it the ordinary way unless the retailer's version wins more new-to-brand buyers per dollar in a lift test, and Walmart's new option to use its audiences in Vibe with attribution on your own site.
Our judgment, built from Bigeye, AMZDudes, Canopy Management, Walmart, Measured, Ad Measurement Weekly and OneElevate: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 11 sourcesWalmart Connect uses Walmart shopper data to reach customers on CTV, social and the web, including VIZIO home screen ads, through a DSP powered by The Trade Desk, with reports tied to Walmart sales.
“VIZIO Home Screen ads are integrated into the VIZIO TV operating system and appear when users power on their TV”
Amazon's streaming TV ads run on Prime Video, Twitch and other publishers with no required minimum, though Amazon recommends $10K per self-service campaign and requires $50K for managed packages.
“Self-service packages have a $10K recommended campaign minimum, and managed-service packages have a $50K campaign minimum.”
Walmart says Vibe advertisers can now target Walmart shopper audiences in CTV campaigns. Measurement runs through Vibe's tools on the advertiser's own site, not on Walmart sales.
“Advertisers can measure results through Vibe’s existing tools, including purchase-level attribution on their own sites and incrementality testing.”
Bigeye, a retail media agency, tells CPG brands to add Walmart offsite and store ads only after Sponsored Search works, and to judge them on incremental sales, not Walmart's reported ROAS.
“Set the measure of success before launch: incremental sales, online and in store, not platform-reported return on ad spend.”
Enrich Labs, which sells an AI marketing agent, says to keep off-Amazon demand in Google and Meta rather than shifting search budget into Amazon DSP, and to cap frequency on Prime Video.
“Do not move search budget into DSP because CPCs feel high.”
Bigeye, a retail media agency, says to fund retail networks by sales volume, buy off-site only after on-site, and run a 4 to 6 week matched-market holdout before raising budgets, since dashboards can't show causation.
“The retailer's dashboard reports attributed sales. It can't tell you which ones the ad caused.”
Walmart says its audiences and closed-loop measurement now reach CTV through Yahoo DSP on VIZIO and Walmart DSP. One Hidden Valley Ranch campaign got 55% incremental reach and 26% more add-to-carts; no sales lift given.
“The campaign delivered 55% incremental reach beyond linear TV”
Measured's CTV panel, over $25M of spend, found streaming about 75% more incremental than linear TV and YouTube CTV and video at 1.6x the category benchmark. Small-budget CTV tests often showed no measurable lift.
“the platform is rarely the variable that decides the outcome”
Canopy Management says Walmart Connect grew 43% in the US, so its cost per click edge over Amazon is narrowing; plan on your own trailing 90-day costs, not old benchmarks.
“Rising costs are a reason to tighten execution before they are a reason to leave.”
AMZDudes, an agency selling Sponsored TV management, says to add Sponsored TV only after other Amazon ads work, and test with $3,000 to $10,000 over 30 to 60 days. Its figures carry no data.
“Sponsored TV is an upper-funnel awareness format, not a direct-response channel.”
Ad Measurement Weekly says retail media closed-loop data shows who bought after an ad, not who would have bought anyway, and each network measures its own way. Ask retailers for lift or geo tests on CTV.
“Treat retail media closed-loop data as a signal, not ground truth.”
Digiday reports Walmart and Kroger want their shopper data to prove TV ads drive sales, with Walmart aiming at smaller advertisers and marketplace sellers. The quoted views come without data.
“retailers believe that shopper data can help advertisers prove their TV ads lead to sales.”
PPC Land reports Walmart is buying Vibe, a self-serve CTV platform with more than 10,000 advertisers, which could later tie streaming ads to actual Walmart purchases and open TV to marketplace sellers.
“Walmart's marketplace sellers, who currently advertise through Walmart Connect's sponsored products and onsite formats, gain a potential path into streaming TV without building programmatic expertise.”
Elevate, an agency, says Vibe.co offers self-serve CTV with no minimums, but advertisers should check it stays open after the Walmart deal and hold it to independent incrementality tests.
“advertisers should test the combined offering and confirm it stays genuinely open rather than narrowing toward Walmart-only buying.”
Walmart announced it would acquire Vibe.co, a self-serve CTV platform with more than 10,000 advertisers, to make TV ads easier for small and mid-sized advertisers using Walmart's shopper data and measurement.
“making CTV more accessible to advertisers without large media teams or specialized resources.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer