Should we run replenishment reminders, and how do we time them?
Our answer
Run replenishment reminders only for products customers use up on a predictable cycle. Time them a few days before customers run out, about day 20 to 25 for a 30-day supply, and stop them when the customer reorders.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 official rules
- 5 practitioners, 8 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 14 sources
- 17 statements
- KB
HRCIOC
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA reminder should land before the customer runs out, with time for delivery. Klaviyo's guides send one about 25 days into a 30-day supply by email and about 20 by text. Top Growth Marketing and 1Digital use day 22 to 25.
One flat delay for every buyer misses heavy and light users (Hello Retail, Clerk.io). Time from each product's cycle first, then from each customer's own reorder gap.
Replenishment is a core flow only where products are used up on a cycle. Tribe and Liquid Lemon treat it as core for those products, and Clerk.io warns against reminders for one-time purchases such as furniture.
Our judgment
- Run reminders only for products customers use up and reorder on a predictable cycle. Leave one-off purchases to cross-sell and win-back, going by Klaviyo's, Hello Retail's and Omnisend's tests for a fit and Clerk.io's furniture example.
- For a 30-day supply, send the first reminder around day 20 to 25. That range spans Klaviyo's about 20 days for texts and about 25 for email and Top Growth Marketing's and 1Digital's day 22 to 25, and fits Hello Retail's 2 to 7 days before run-out and Omnisend's few days before customers run out.
- Set the delay per product from your own reorder data, then move to each customer's own interval once they have reordered. That goes by Klaviyo's advice to time from established buying cycles, Postscript's per-variant median, Hello Retail's per-customer cadence and Eightx's advice to pull your own median.
- Keep the sequence to one or two reminders that stop on reorder, and hold any offer for a late follow-up, first-time buyers or higher-priced items. That goes by Klaviyo's 1 to 2 messages, its two reminders with a later incentive and Postscript's cancellation trigger.
Our judgment, built from Klaviyo, Hello Retail, Omnisend, Clerk.io, Top Growth Marketing, 1Digital, Postscript and Eightx: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
17 statements from 14 sourcesKlaviyo says for a 30 day supplement, send a reminder about 25 days after purchase, then two reminders and one incentive follow-up after the buying cycle passes. Klaviyo sells the flows.
“send a reminder email about 25 days after customers enter the flow.”
Klaviyo's help page advises timing a replenishment text for before the customer runs out, for example day 20 of a 30-day buying cycle, with at most 1 to 2 messages per recipient and a promotion for first-time recipients.
“Typically, replenishment flows don't need many messages, at most 1-2 per recipient.”
Klaviyo says a winback flow should target customers inactive longer than the average buying cycle, run three emails with an incentive, and leave out replenishable items with a set cycle.
“We recommend keeping your winback flow to three emails per recipient”
BLKDG, a Klaviyo agency, splits post-purchase emails by first-time and repeat buyers and times reorder reminders to how long the product lasts. Per Klaviyo, post-purchase flows average $1.80 revenue per recipient.
“Judge your post-purchase emails on what they're for: how many first-time buyers place a second order.”
BLKDG, a Klaviyo agency, says time win-back email to your store's repurchase interval, hold any incentive for the second email, and pull replenishable items out of win-back flows.
“Hold the incentive for the second win-back email, where it reaches only the people the first one didn't move.”
1Digital, which builds email flows, advises 5 to 8 post-purchase emails over 45 days, a review request 10 to 12 days after delivery, and replenishment reminders timed to usage, such as day 22 to 25 for a 30-day supply.
“Day 10-12 after delivery is the sweet spot for most physical product categories.”
Omnisend, which sells replenishment automations, says replenishment emails suit predictably consumed products, sent a few days before customers typically run out. It suggests testing offers like 10% off within 48 hours.
“a few days before customers typically run out”
Liquid Lemon, a Klaviyo partner agency, lists welcome, abandoned cart, browse abandonment, post-purchase, winback and replenishment as flows to run all the time.
“Core flows like welcome, abandoned cart, and post-purchase compound from the first send”
Postscript says Repeat's SMS reminders are timed per product: replenishment just before the median reorder interval, late reorder around the 75th percentile, and a second-order nudge near the 25th.
“nobody gets asked to restock something they just bought.”
CommercePundit, which builds subscription stores, says subscriptions fit products customers already reorder, physical subscriptions lose 5-7% of subscribers a month, and LTV should be at least 3x acquisition cost.
“Physical product subscriptions typically lose 5-7% of their subscriber base every month.”
Hello Retail, which sells personalization software, says time replenishment emails to each customer's own purchase cadence: 2-3 days before predicted run-out for supplements and coffee, 5-7 days for quarterly skincare.
“If they have bought it three times, the average interval between their purchases is the best available predictor”
Clerk.io, which sells email software, says replenishment emails should fire on each customer's buying pattern, not a flat 30-day reminder. A shrinking reorder cycle means good timing; a lengthening one means too late.
“Replenishment is a timing flow, not a campaign flow.”
Tribe, which builds Klaviyo flows, says brands need six to eight core flows live first: welcome, abandoned checkout, browse abandonment, post-purchase, win-back, replenishment, VIP and sunset.
“These are the flows that should be live before anything else.”
Eightx relays a 2024 dataset of 156,110 online shoppers: 50.3% of repeat orders came within 30 days, 76.4% within 90 and 96.3% within a year. It says to build flows off your own median, not the mean.
“50.3% of repeat orders happen inside 30 days. 76.4% inside 90 days. Only 3.7% later than a year.”
Charle, a Shopify agency, launches welcome, browse abandonment and abandoned cart flows in weeks 1 to 4, then post-purchase, back-in-stock and win-back flows in weeks 5 to 8.
“Launch your three highest-impact flows first: welcome series, browse abandonment, and abandoned cart.”
Top Growth Marketing, an agency, splits post-purchase email flows into first-time and repeat buyer paths, runs them 30 to 60 days, and asks for reviews 14 days after delivery for consumables or 21 for durables.
“Split the flow by first-time vs. repeat buyer”
Flowium, a Klaviyo agency, uses a four-email winback flow: a small discount with a deadline, a follow-up a day later, then a bigger discount 7 days after that. Skincare might start winback at 60 days.
“we prefer to use a four-part sequence for customer winback flows”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer