Should we promote existing Reddit posts as ads?
Our answer
Promote an existing post only when the community already rewarded it, by Reddit's measure an upvote rate of 75% or higher with active comments. Use a conversion goal such as Sales, and keep new ads for most spend.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 2 official rules
- 1 dataset, 2 practitioners, 1 opinion or claim
- Sources
- 4 sources
- 6 statements
- R
SM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentReddit itself sets the bar for which posts to promote. Its guide tells you to promote organic posts with upvote rates of 75% or higher and active comment sections. You build the ad in Ads Manager from the Post Library.
Promotion works best on content that is already landing (Stackmatix, paid media agency). Stackmatix also finds an organic post in the right community sometimes beats paid, so the lesson can be to promote less and take part more.
On Reddit, conversion programs pay while awareness buys under-perform. Measured (incrementality testing firm) found awareness buys under-performed on Reddit while conversion programs paid at every brand in its panel that ran them. Mintec says Reddit's ads run on click and conversion intent.
Our judgment
Promote a post only when it has already earned a strong upvote rate and an active comment thread, and keep new ads for most spend. Run a promoted post on a conversion goal such as Sales and judge it on cost per purchase or lead. Stackmatix's description of the post's Promote button lists only traffic, engagement and awareness goals, while Measured found awareness buys under-performed on Reddit.
Our judgment, built from Reddit, Stackmatix, Measured and Mintec: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
6 statements from 4 sourcesMintec, which sells ad management, notes Reddit's ad objectives leave out engagement because its ads business rests on clicks and conversions in communities, not boosted posts.
“its ads business is built on click and conversion intent inside communities, not on engagement farming.”
Measured's panel of enterprise consumer brands puts Reddit at 1.6x the panel average, the most consistent platform, best for considered purchases. Awareness buys underperformed.
“conversion- and consideration-objective Reddit programs delivered solid positive iROAS at every brand in the panel that ran them”
Stackmatix, which sells Reddit ad management, says to promote posts already doing well organically, judge them on conversions rather than upvotes, and sometimes take part more instead of paying.
“Engagement inside Reddit is a weak proxy for business outcome, so tie the campaign to a conversion event you actually care about: signup, demo, purchase.”
Reddit says its Redditor Highlights, which embed users' posts about a brand in ads, lifted click-through 10.7% on average for awareness campaigns, with no sample or method given.
“+10.7% lift in CTR”
Reddit suggests promoting organic posts with 75% or higher upvote rates and active comments, with budget for at least three conversions per ad group. Its claim of better ROI has no figure.
“Start with a daily budget that will get you at least three conversions per ad group to ensure sufficient data for analysis.”
Reddit says Reddit Pro users can promote their organic profile posts as paid ads with one button on reddit.com. It describes the feature, not results.
“extend the reach of their organic profile posts as paid advertisements on Reddit with the click of a (promote) button”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer