Should we offer product customization or personalization online?
Our answer
Offer customization where your product naturally carries a name or design and orders can go to production without rework. Start simple, keep the customizer short, add a live preview for complex designs and sell personalized items as final sale.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 4 official rules, 1 practitioner, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 10 statements
- CUG
ZCCKECBI
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentSimple options are often enough. Customily (product personalization app maker), which sells live previews, argues static text fields still suit simple engravings, low priced products and stores testing demand. Zakeke (product customizer software maker), which sells configurators, advises that standard product options may be enough.
A simpler customizer sold more in one test. Merging two customizers into one with a text orientation toggle lifted conversion 12.6% and revenue per visitor 16.7% at a hat store (Clean Commit, Shopify development agency).
Personalized goods can be final sale. EU and UK law exempt goods made to the buyer's specifications or clearly personalized from the 14-day right to cancel, and Shopify lets you mark custom items final sale.
Our judgment
- Offer customization only where the product naturally carries a name or design and orders reach production without rework. Customily ties the payoff to gifts, jewelry, apparel and print on demand, and Zakeke warns that a preview which doesn't feed production leaves staff recreating designs by hand.
- Start with a short text field or a few options, keep the customizer short and add a live preview as designs grow. Customily and Zakeke both say simple options can suffice for simple personalization, and Clean Commit's test gained by merging two customizers and was judged on revenue per visitor as well as conversion.
- Treat Kickflip's 150% uplift as a seller's claim rather than an expected result. Kickflip gives no source for the figure.
- Sell personalized items as final sale and say so on the product page. EU and UK law exempt them from the right to cancel, Shopify lets you mark custom items final sale, and Baymard Institute finds 60% of users look for return policy information on the product page.
Our judgment, built from Customily, Zakeke, Clean Commit, Kickflip, European Commission, UK Government, Shopify and Baymard Institute: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 8 sourcesUK consumer contract rules exclude goods made to the consumer's specifications or clearly personalised from the distance-selling cancellation right.
“the supply of goods that are made to the consumer's specifications or are clearly personalised”
Shopify lets merchants mark products or collections as final sale, so customers can't request returns or cancellations for them; examples include perishable, custom or personal care items. Bundles can't be final sale.
“Your customers can't submit return or cancellation requests for final sale items.”
UK law: customers can cancel within 14 days of receiving an item and have 14 more days to return it. You must refund within 14 days of getting it back, including standard delivery.
“They do not have to provide a reason. You cannot deduct any fees from their refund, unless the item has been used or damaged.”
Zakeke, which sells product configurators, says you probably do not need one if options are standard variants with few combinations, no preview, no dependencies, and no effect on price or production.
“Standard ecommerce product options may be sufficient.”
In one Shopify hat store's A/B test, merging two customizers into one simpler flow raised conversion 12.6% and revenue per visitor 16.7%. No sample size or significance is given.
“Simplifying customization options reduced choice paralysis.”
The European Commission says the EU's 14-day cooling-off right to return online purchases does not apply to goods made to order or clearly personalised.
“goods made to order or clearly personalised”
Baymard's benchmark of 155+ large US and European sites rates most product pages mediocre or worse (52% desktop, 62% mobile) and lists fixes such as size buttons, in-scale images and a return policy link.
“52% of desktop, 62% of mobile, and 64% of app ecommerce sites have an overall “mediocre or worse” UX performance for their product pages.”
Customily, which sells personalization software, lists survey figures such as 61% willing to pay more for personalization, with no named source or sample and none from its own merchants.
“61% willing to pay more for personalized experiences”
Customily, which sells a live preview personalization app, says live previews match customer expectations to the finished product, while static customizers still suit simple engravings and cheap items. No data.
“Static customization is not obsolete. It can still be appropriate for:”
Kickflip, which sells a product configurator, claims product personalization lifts conversion 150% on average over static product flows, with no named source, sample or method.
“Companies using product personalization report average conversion uplifts of 150% compared to traditional static product flows.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer