All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

How should Pinterest targeting be set: broad, interests or keywords?

The PrevailingPublished Oct 28, 2026

Our answer

Leave catalog Sales campaigns to Pinterest's own targeting. Once your budget carries a second campaign, build a manual keyword campaign with at least 25 keywords per ad group. Test interests and customer actalikes in separate ad groups.

Confidence
Medium
Strongest proof
9 official rules
6 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
Sources
7 sources
17 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Catalog campaigns need no added targeting. Pinterest says keyword or interest targeting is not necessary for catalog sales campaigns and turns Performance+ targeting on by default. AdManage.ai (ad launch tool maker) and Trackbee (Shopify conversion tracking app) advise against narrowing it.

Agencies build manual campaigns on keywords. Tailored Edge Marketing, Black Propeller and Stackmatix all do, and treat interests as a wider layer. Pinterest recommends at least 25 keywords per ad group.

Running a catalog campaign beside manual campaigns shows you more than automation alone. Simple Pin Media (Pinterest ads agency) runs a Performance+ catalog campaign for every ecommerce client beside manual campaigns, because the manual ones show who converts.

Our judgment

  • Run the catalog Sales campaign without added targeting and a keyword-led manual campaign beside it. That follows Pinterest's rule for catalog campaigns and Simple Pin Media's pairing of Performance+ with manual campaigns, with the keyword structure Tailored Edge Marketing, Black Propeller and Stackmatix agree on.
  • Add the keyword campaign only once the budget carries a second campaign. An account starts with one Sales campaign (Pinterest account structure), Tailored Edge Marketing keeps a new account to the few ad groups its budget supports, and Pinterest's delivery typically needs 50 to 200 conversions a week to learn.
  • Test interests and actalikes in their own ad groups, not mixed into the keyword ones. We side with Stackmatix over Black Propeller because separate ad groups keep the keyword read clean, as Tailored Edge Marketing's interest discovery layer also implies.
  • Leave Performance+ targeting on and read the (Automatic) rows against your own cost per purchase before switching it off. Pinterest turns it on by default and reports it separately, and Trackbee finds automation usually beats hand narrowing.

Our judgment, built from Pinterest, Simple Pin Media, Tailored Edge Marketing, Black Propeller, Stackmatix and Trackbee: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

17 statements from 7 sources
  • PinterestUndatedSupports

    Pinterest says advertisers can combine audience lists, actalikes, interests, keywords, demographics and placement targeting, and Performance+ targeting widens reach to people with similar searches or interests.

    “To increase the possibility of someone seeing your ad, we recommend targeting all placements”

    Read it on help.pinterest.com

  • PinterestUndatedSupports

    Pinterest's Performance+ targeting, on by default for new campaigns, uses your ad's visuals to widen interest and keyword targeting without changing location, age or audience lists. It gives no figures.

    “Pinterest Performance+ targeting is switched on by default for new campaigns in Ads Manager, but you can switch it off at any time.”

    Read it on help.pinterest.com

  • PinterestUndatedSupports

    Pinterest says shopping ads need a business account, a catalog uploaded as product Pins and product groups, and that keyword or interest targeting is not needed for sales campaigns.

    “Note: Keyword or interest targeting is not necessary for sales campaigns.”

    Read it on help.pinterest.com

  • PinterestUndatedCaveat

    Pinterest says Performance+ is a toggle for Consideration, Leads or Sales campaigns, keeps some targeting such as keywords, locations and customer lists, and uses its own automated bidding.

    “Activate Pinterest Performance+ campaigns with a toggle at the beginning of campaign creation for Consideration, Leads or Sales campaigns”

    Read it on help.pinterest.com

  • PinterestUndatedSupports

    Pinterest allows up to 20,000 keywords per ad group and recommends at least 25, with broad, phrase, exact and negative match types.

    “You can use up to 20,000 keywords per ad group and for the best results we recommend using at least 25 keywords per group.”

    Read it on help.pinterest.com

  • PinterestUndatedSupports

    Pinterest says interest targeting reaches people by their interests, tastes and life events, and advises testing both broad interests and precise ones.

    “To refine your audience, test both broad interests (“living rooms”) and precise interests (“mid-century modern”).”

    Read it on help.pinterest.com

  • PinterestUndatedCaveat

    Pinterest lets you target site visitors, customer lists of emails or mobile ad IDs, engagement audiences and actalikes. A customer list needs at least 100 matches before it can be used.

    “Once your list has at least 100 matches”

    Read it on help.pinterest.com

  • PinterestUndatedCaveat

    Pinterest says 50 to 200 conversions a week is usually enough for its system to learn, and advises no more than two rounds of changes a week, with three to five days to recalibrate after each.

    “Typically we see that 50-200 conversions per week is sufficient for our delivery system to learn who it's best to show your ads to.”

    Read it on help.pinterest.com

  • AdManage.aiOct 24, 2026Supports

    AdManage.ai, which sells ad launching software, warns against layering Meta-style keyword and interest targeting on Pinterest shopping campaigns, and repeats Pinterest's 5x CPA budget and 10 ads rules.

    “One of the biggest 2026 mistakes we see is importing a Meta habit into Pinterest and layering keyword and interest targeting onto shopping campaigns.”

    Read it on admanage.ai

  • Simple Pin MediaSep 29, 2026Supports

    Erin of Simple Pin Media, a Pinterest ads agency, runs a Performance+ catalog campaign for every e-commerce client alongside manual campaigns, saying Performance+ alone does not give enough data.

    “I really don’t think doing all Performance Plus gives you the data you need to make really good decisions”

    Read it on simplepinmedia.com

  • Tailored Edge MarketingSep 26, 2026Caveat

    Tailored Edge Marketing, which sells paid social, tells new Shopify brands on Pinterest to start with one Sales campaign and few ad groups, often one prospecting group, splitting only when economics differ.

    “Every ad group should answer a commercial question that could change the next decision.”

    Read it on tailorededgemarketing.com

  • PinterestSep 17, 2026Supports

    Pinterest announced self-serve A/B testing across creative, targeting and Performance+, plus Visual Search Ads in beta for lower-funnel objectives.

    “support lower funnel objectives and are compatible with Pinterest Performance+”

    Read it on newsroom.pinterest.com

  • StackmatixSep 3, 2026Supports

    Stackmatix suggests two or three layered Pinterest interests, phrase-match keywords with negatives, and actalikes seeded from top customers at 1% to 3% similarity, widening to 5% to 10% once profitable.

    “Start with a 1% to 3% similarity range for precision, then expand to 5% to 10% once the narrower audience proves profitable.”

    Read it on stackmatix.com

  • StackmatixSep 3, 2026Disagrees

    Stackmatix, a paid media agency, suggests one Pinterest campaign per objective, 3 to 6 ad groups per prospecting campaign, 2 to 4 Pins per ad group, and no changes for at least seven days.

    “The proven setup is one campaign per objective, ad groups split by audience or keyword theme, and 2 to 4 Pins per ad group.”

    Read it on stackmatix.com

  • Tailored Edge MarketingJul 23, 2026Supports

    Tailored Edge Marketing says Pinterest ads run on a keyword auction, so build ad groups around query themes and consolidate until each can reach 50 to 200 conversions a week. No data.

    “Pinterest ads run on a keyword auction. Build the account around queries.”

    Read it on tailorededgemarketing.com

  • Black PropellerJul 2, 2026Supports

    Black Propeller, a paid social agency, says Pinterest keywords work like search terms, build a 1% actalike from your best customers once a custom audience has 100 records, and keep manual targeting for B2B.

    “A one percent Actalike audience built from your highest-LTV customers consistently outperforms interest-based prospecting at comparable or lower CPA.”

    Read it on blackpropeller.com

  • TrackbeeJun 20, 2026Supports

    Trackbee, which sells Pinterest conversion tracking, says broad targeting with Pinterest's automation usually finds cheaper clicks than narrow audiences, and suggests Performance+ to start. No data given.

    “Narrow, high-competition audiences cost more per click.”

    Read it on trackbee.io

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Pinterest ads