Should we run TikTok Pangle or other network placements?
Our answer
Keep sales and lead campaigns on TikTok placement only. Test TikTok Ad Network, formerly Pangle, only in its own ad group with a separate budget, judged on orders or leads in your own records.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 TikTok rules
- 6 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 10 statements
- T
MMD
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAgencies advise keeping TikTok Ad Network off sales and lead campaigns. Mintec (TikTok ads agency) advises holding it for lead generation and ecommerce with tight cost per purchase or cost per lead targets, testing it only in its own ad group.
The case for TikTok Ad Network rests on TikTok's own figures. Its 65% better cost per acquisition and 63% better ROAS come from its internal data. Agency buyers told Digiday they want proof of incremental reach first.
Placement is fixed once you set it. TikTok says placement can't be changed after an ad group is created. Its block list covers up to 10,000 apps but can cut impressions.
Our judgment
Keeping sales and lead campaigns on TikTok placement by default is the side we took. It follows Mintec, The Keyword's reading that measuring the network separately has to be set up when the ad group is created, and Mega Digital's Select Placement for conversion-focused campaigns. We treat Lemon8 and Global App Bundle like the network on sales and lead campaigns, going by Collective Measures' opt-out of Lemon8 (reported by Digiday) and Mega Digital's advice to avoid partner apps when brand image matters. Judge any test on orders or booked leads in your own records rather than TikTok's reporting. Mintec counts conversions your CRM can't find as cost, and ContentGrip says TikTok has not published enough independent evidence for the network.
Our judgment, built from Mintec, The Keyword, Mega Digital, Digiday, TikTok and ContentGrip: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 6 sourcesA trade report on TikTok's ad network says advertisers see only a top 100 publisher list and can block apps but not restrict a campaign to an approved list. Measuring the network separately must be set at setup.
“The help pages describe a way to block apps but no way to restrict a campaign to an approved list, which is what a whitelist would do.”
ContentGrip says TikTok has not published enough independent evidence on how its app ad network performs against alternatives, and advises separating incremental reach from overlap with audiences already reached.
“The company has not yet published enough independent evidence to show how TTAN performance compares with established cross-app alternatives across categories.”
Mintec, which sells TikTok management, advises keeping the TikTok Ad Network off by default for direct response and testing it only in an isolated campaign with placement reports and CRM checks. No client results.
“Never let it blend into your always-on structure, or you will never be able to read what it contributed.”
TikTok's Ad Network is now open to US advertisers. TikTok reports 65% better CPA and 63% better ROAS in early tests, but these are its own internal figures, including a 2024 test.
“These are TikTok's own figures.”
Agency executives quoted by Digiday, who sell media buying, are wary of TikTok's wider ad network. One has opted out of Lemon8, and another says a bigger network does not move more money to TikTok. No performance data.
“Having a larger ad network doesn’t make us move more money into TikTok,”
TikTok has merged manual and Smart+ setup into one flow with full, partial or no automation; each ad works like an asset group with up to 50 creatives. It may not be available to everyone yet.
“you can tailor your campaign to full automation, partial automation, or fully manual.”
TikTok's help page says TikTok Ad Network reaches nearly 400,000 apps and over 1 billion daily users, offers DoubleVerify and Integral Ad Science brand safety, and fixes placement once an ad group is created.
“Your placement is selected when creating an ad group and cannot be changed after it has been created.”
TikTok's help page says the Ad Network block list can reduce impressions and performance, covers only TikTok Ad Network placements, and holds up to 10,000 bundle IDs.
“Using a block list may result in fewer ad impressions and potentially poorer performance due to less traffic.”
TikTok says its Ads Manager spreads budget across placements by performance and avoids putting everything in one. Placement is chosen when the ad group is created and cannot be changed afterward.
“Your placement is selected when creating an ad group and cannot be changed after it has been created.”
Mega Digital, which sells TikTok ad management, recommends Automatic Placement for a new campaign to test creative, then Select Placement to scale what works. It shows no results.
“start with Automatic Placement for data collection, then switch to Select Placement to scale what works best.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer