Should we optimize for the number of buyers (volume) or for revenue (value)?
Our answer
Run two campaigns on the same ads, one optimized for the number of purchases and one for purchase value with a ROAS goal. Let results set the split.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 Meta rules
- 1 dataset, 9 practitioners
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 13 statements
M
HCPBH
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentRunning volume and value campaigns side by side is standard practice. Common Thread Collective (CTC) duplicates every ad into a value and a volume setup in every account. Andrew Faris runs a cost-capped volume campaign beside a ROAS-goal value campaign.
Value bidding finds bigger carts, and volume bidding holds costs flat. ROAS bidding lets Meta find buyers with bigger carts at a cost per purchase that can be higher, while cost-capped bidding holds every conversion under one threshold (CTC, August 2026).
Value bidding needs a spread of order values. Meta requires a good distribution of values across products for its highest value bid strategy, and Flighted uses a cost per result goal when purchases are of about equal value.
Our judgment
- No fixed budget split between the two campaigns is worth copying. CTC runs both on every ad, and the split varies by account, so your own results set it.
- Judge the volume and value campaigns on new-customer cost and blended revenue. We take this from CTC's practice of setting on-platform targets from new-customer revenue and incrementality, not Meta-reported ROAS.
- Shift toward volume when you are judged on new-customer count. CTC found that maximizing purchase count drifts toward the cheapest product, and Cody Plofker says Jones Road ran its campaigns other than kits on conversion optimization for incremental results.
- Test a ROAS goal on a volume campaign only in a time-boxed A/B test. Jon Loomer calls the option worth testing, and Andrew Faris runs a cost-capped volume campaign.
Our judgment, built from Common Thread Collective, Cody Plofker, Jon Loomer and Andrew Faris: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
13 statements from 8 sourcesMeta says its highest value bid strategy needs a good spread of order values across products, and suits advertisers who want higher-value purchases rather than more purchases.
“Highest value requires a good distribution of values across different products.”
Meta's bid strategy documentation says Highest Volume spends the full budget, while cost cap, bid cap and minimum ROAS can under-deliver. Cost cap limits are not guaranteed.
“adherence to cost cap limits is not guaranteed”
Cody Plofker says Jones Road ran kits and higher-AOV offers on value optimization and others on conversion optimization; at Winks a 90-day offer was cut after two days for lack of signal. No data.
“because we just need more signal”
Andrew Faris's standard setup runs the same ads in two campaigns: one cost-capped for highest volume and one with a ROAS goal for highest value, both on Incremental Attribution.
Ben Heath says switching sales campaigns from maximize number of conversions to maximize value of conversions prioritizes higher-value customers and improves return on ad spend.
“maximize value of conversions... factor[s] in how valuable a new customer is to your business”
Common Thread Collective, studying about 320 accounts, says ROAS-based bidding lets Meta seek higher cart-size buyers, while cost-constrained bidding caps every conversion under one threshold. It builds on value bidding.
“ROAS-based bidding gives the algorithm more flexibility to find high-value buyers.”
Andrew Faris says Incremental Attribution gave a much smaller gain on highest-value (ROAS goal) campaigns than on volume campaigns, and sometimes a slightly worse result, for his agency's clients.
CTC's default is value optimization with a minimum ROAS on 7-day click, because maximizing purchase count on a fixed budget always drifts toward the cheapest product.
CTC duplicates every ad into both a value-optimized and a volume-optimized setup in every account, and which one gets more spend varies by account.
Meta's profit optimization values conversions by the profit you send with each purchase. It needs at least 3 distinct profit values and 100 conversions a week, ideally 30 a day per campaign.
“Make sure your profit values aren't just a fixed percentage of your purchase values”
Jon Loomer reports Meta now lets you pick the ROAS Goal bid strategy while maximizing the number of conversions; before, it was only available when maximizing value. He says it is worth testing.
“It's certainly worth testing.”
Flighted says to use Highest Value or a ROAS goal when purchase values vary, so Meta favors higher-margin orders, and cost per result when every conversion is worth about the same. Test new products on Highest Volume.
“helps Meta prioritize higher-margin purchases over lower-value ones”
Conor Rowland says HexClad uses value optimization because its hero product is a $700 set, but also runs lowest-cost volume bidding to win lower-order-value customers cheaply. He says to run both.
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer