How should we monitor uptime and checkout errors?
Our answer
Subscribe to Shopify's and your payment providers' status pages, and check your checkout path from outside. Alert on drops in orders or checkout completion against your own normal, and read failed payments in abandoned checkouts.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 5 official rules
- 2 datasets, 3 practitioners, 5 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 15 statements
U
CLSTX
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentShopify's status page can miss problems at your store. Shopify points stores to it, to payment providers' pages and to alerts on abandoned checkout spikes, but says issues hitting a small share of stores may not show there.
Failures often come from third parties, so a check has to run the real checkout (UptimeRobot, an uptime monitoring software maker, and Checkly, a site monitoring software maker). UptimeRobot found failures above its baseline on every holiday peak day it measured.
A sudden daily drop in orders or conversion is the usual sign of a broken checkout (Trackbee, a Shopify conversion tracking app, and Top Growth Marketing, a Performance Max agency). Stratgik (ecommerce systems firm) adds a daily test order on top.
Our judgment
- Treat Shopify's status page as one signal, not the alarm. Shopify says issues affecting a small percentage of stores may not show there, and its enterprise blog says payment outages often show as partial failures.
- Run an outside check through the real checkout and register it as an authorized crawler on Shopify. The World of Books engineer writing for Checkly warns that expired signatures make every check look like the store is down, and Stratgik says only a test order shows customers can buy.
- Set alerts against your own normal rather than a benchmark. Littledata's stores range from 15% at the bottom tenth to 74% at the top tenth around a median of 49%, and Shopify, Trackbee and Top Growth Marketing read a sudden drop as the sign of trouble.
- Keep full alert coverage for the 12 days from the Monday of Black Friday week, as UptimeRobot advises. It found failures above baseline on every one of those days in both years it measured.
Our judgment, built from Shopify, Checkly, Stratgik, Littledata, Trackbee, Top Growth Marketing and UptimeRobot: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 8 sourcesShopify's status page shows whether checkout, storefront and third party services are working and offers update subscriptions, but warns issues hitting a small share of stores may not appear.
“Some issues affecting a small percentage of stores may not be reflected here.”
Shopify says failed payments usually leave an abandoned checkout, not an order; if every method fails for everyone, check test mode, provider account and status pages. Banks decide declines.
“If every payment method fails for every customer, then the cause is usually a store-level setting or an outage.”
Shopify says most card declines are generic, collecting the CVV can significantly improve decline rates, and Shopify Payments routes charges to the processor most likely to approve them.
“Collecting the CVV can significantly improve your decline rates.”
Shopify's alert_displayed pixel event records error messages and warnings shown at checkout, by type such as payment, delivery, discount or inventory errors. It fires only on checkout.
“This event is only available on checkout.”
Shopify's web pixel event ui_extension_errored logs when a checkout extension fails to render because of an uncaught error in its code. It fires only on checkout.
“This event is only available on checkout.”
UptimeRobot, which sells monitoring, says a store can lose sales without going offline and to watch payment, fraud, tax and shipping rate services first, since ads keep spending when checkout fails.
“Advertising campaigns may continue spending even when shoppers can’t complete checkout.”
UptimeRobot, which sells monitoring, found failures across monitored sites and services above baseline on all 24 days of the 2024 and 2025 Black Friday windows, peaking four days after Cyber Monday.
“Checkout depends on infrastructure you don’t control too.”
Littledata, which sells Shopify analytics, reports a median 49% of checkout sessions completing purchase across 435 of its Shopify stores: 63% on mobile, 35% on desktop. Top 10% reach 74%.
“Of the sessions that started checkout, the share that went on to purchase.”
Stratgik, which sells store maintenance, gives a checklist by frequency, led by a daily end-to-end test order, and says hosted platforms still leave apps, themes, checkout and speed to you.
“A broken checkout can go unnoticed for hours. A daily test order is the single cheapest safeguard you have.”
Top Growth Marketing, an agency, says to track 5 to 7 Shopify metrics weekly (revenue, sessions, conversion rate, AOV, returning customer rate, top products) and benchmark each traffic source separately.
“A sudden drop could indicate a broken checkout, slow load times, or a bad product page. Track this daily.”
Trackbee suggests watching revenue, orders, MER, spend and CAC daily, the new versus returning split and channel results weekly, and cohorts, LTV and margin monthly.
“If a number would not change what you do next, it belongs in a monthly report, not on your daily screen.”
Xero suggests checking uptime, orders and live ads daily, traffic and conversion weekly, order value, CAC and ROAS monthly, and lifetime value, retention and margin quarterly. No data.
“monthly and quarterly reviews give you the most useful averages.”
A World of Books QA engineer, on Checkly's blog, monitors his Shopify checkout with real orders refunded at once, and warns that expired crawler signatures make checks show the whole store as down.
“When they expire, every check returns a challenge page and it looks like your entire store is down.”
Shopify says payment outages can show up as delays or higher decline rates, so set alerts on signals like a spike in abandoned carts and watch Shopify's and your payment provider's status pages.
“If Visa fails but Amex or wallets work, the issue may lie with the network or issuer.”
Shopify claims 99.9% uptime for stores, with no period or method given, and warns that soft downtime, where a site loads but works poorly, is harder to notice than an outage.
“Unlike hard downtime, where it’s obvious that your website is defective, soft downtime can be more difficult to notice.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer