How should we structure the main menu and navigation?
Our answer
Put product categories at the top level of the menu and keep each level to about 10 options. Make headings clickable, add View all on mobile, and test any menu redesign on revenue per visitor.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 6 controlled tests
- 1 official rule, 6 practitioners
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 13 statements
- BCBI
CCSA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentShoppers need categories up front and short lists. Some 22% of sites don't make categories the first mobile menu level, and shoppers feel overwhelmed past about 10 subcategory options (Baymard Institute, ecommerce UX research firm).
Most sites miss the cues that keep shoppers oriented. In Baymard Institute's benchmarks, 96% of sites don't highlight the current section and 42% of mobile sites lack View all at each level.
Menu redesigns can win or lose. Menu image tests by Blend Commerce (Shopify CRO agency) ranged from a 42% rise to a 4% fall in revenue per visitor, and a Clean Commit change to Hats cut conversion 10.9%.
Our judgment
- Make product categories the top level of the menu and keep each level to about 10 options. Push shared attributes into filters, since Baymard Institute's benchmarks back visible, manageable categories and Shopify's two nested levels fit that shape.
- Make headings clickable, add View all at each mobile level and highlight the current section. Most large sites miss these in Baymard Institute's benchmarks, and shoppers rely on them to orient.
- Treat category images and other menu redesigns as tests, not defaults. Blend Commerce's image tests and Clean Commit's Hats change went both ways.
- Change an established menu in steps, since returning customers rely on its layout.
Our judgment, built from Baymard Institute, Shopify, Blend Commerce, Clean Commit and Shoplift: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
13 statements from 6 sourcesShopify says stores with many products can group them into collections under drop-down menus. Most themes support up to two nested levels, and footer menus show only top-level items.
“Most themes support up to two levels of nested drop-down menus.”
Baymard's research on 180+ US and European sites says mobile menus should put product categories at the top level, subdivide near 10 categories, and desktop hover menus need a 300 to 500ms delay.
“it’s key to reduce navigation friction by providing product categories as top-level mobile main navigation options.”
Baymard's usability research on 180+ US and European sites found 79% use categories where filters should be used, which stops shoppers refining by everything they care about.
“79% of Sites Use Categories When Filters Should Be Used”
Blend Commerce's test for Fame found adding category images to the mobile menu lifted revenue per visitor 7.75% and order value 6.61%, with no confidence level or sample size, so the result is directional.
“No confidence level or sample size was supplied, so the uplifts should be treated as directional.”
In one memorial store's test, adding product images to mobile menu links cut conversion 2% and revenue per visitor 4% across all traffic. A gain appeared only after excluding some visitors after the fact.
“Across all traffic, Variant 1 reduced conversion rate by 2%, revenue per visitor by 4% and average order value by 2%.”
Shoplift, which sells A/B testing software, says even a better rebuilt site causes short-term friction as returning customers lose their mental map, and recovery after a replatform takes 60 to 180 days.
“Even when the new Shopify product pages and checkout are measurably better than what they replaced, the change itself causes short-term friction.”
Baymard's mobile benchmark lists common gaps: 42% of sites lack a View All option at each catalog level, 66% don't show applied filters in an overview, and 73% hide color swatches in product lists.
“Display “Applied Filters” in an Overview (66% Don’t)”
Shopify's SEO lead advises working in stages: fix on-page SEO for top product pages, then internal links, then backlink outreach, starting with pages that already get traffic or sales.
“backlinks work best after your own pages are useful and easy to navigate.”
Blend Commerce's test of mobile category menus for one pet food store found adding images cut conversion 11%; a version with images and social proof raised add-to-cart 5%, with revenue flat.
“mobile navigation changes can influence buying momentum, but should be judged across the full funnel, not engagement alone.”
Atilus, a web agency, tells plumbing companies to give each service its own page rather than routing visitors through a general services page, which adds a step many skip. No data given.
“Navigation that routes every visitor through a general services page adds a step that many won’t bother with.”
In one store's A/B test by Blend Commerce, grouping coffees in the menu by flavour profile lifted revenue per visitor 11% and order value 9%, but adding extra copy to subcategory titles hurt purchasing.
“Variant 1 introduced a revised navigation structure grouping coffees by flavour profile: Bright, Balanced, and Bold.”
In Blend Commerce's 21-day test for Vegepod, adding images to the mobile menu raised conversion 14% and revenue per visitor 42%. Sample size and significance are not stated.
“Conversion rate increased by 14%, revenue per visitor rose by 42%, and average order value grew by 24%.”
In one Clean Commit client test, renaming Headwear to Hats and moving it to top-level navigation lifted clicks 2.6% but cut conversion 10.9%; the result was inconclusive.
“"Hats" as a label improved clickthrough but did not convert to sales.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer