How should a marketing dashboard be laid out for leadership?
Our answer
Give leadership one screen of 5 to 7 profit numbers, led for a consumer brand by contribution margin against target. Show each against target, prior period and trend. Keep channel detail on a second layer and review weekly.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 5 practitioners
- 7 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 12 statements
AFKIS1
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentProfit numbers go on top and channel numbers underneath. Admetrics, an ecommerce analytics software maker, puts total sales divided by total ad spend (MER), net revenue, contribution margin, blended customer acquisition cost, payback and lifetime value trend on one executive screen.
Keep the top view short and in context. Keen and Improvado, which sell marketing software, cap it at 5 to 7 metrics, each shown against goal, prior period or trend. Stackmatix, a paid media agency, keeps it to five or fewer.
Monthly is too slow for ecommerce. Futureproof, an ecommerce bookkeeping service, argues this and pairs weekly reviews of key metrics with a cash forecast.
Our judgment
Lead a consumer brand's view with contribution margin dollars against target, because we govern spend by it (The metric that governs total spend) and both Admetrics and Futureproof put it on the leadership view. Hold the top view to 5 to 7 numbers, the range Keen and Improvado give, which sits between Stackmatix's five or fewer and 1ClickReport's 5 to 8. Review it weekly with a monthly planning look, following Admetrics and Futureproof, rather than only the monthly or quarterly formal reviews Keen describes.
Our judgment, built from Admetrics, Futureproof, Keen, Improvado, Stackmatix and 1ClickReport: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
12 statements from 10 sourcesRidge CEO Sean Frank describes a monthly scorecard of about 200 numbers, including a revenue-to-EBITDA ladder, channel growth, MER read as a trend, new and returning revenue and weeks of inventory.
“% shows speed, $ shows scale”
Stackmatix, an agency, says an executive dashboard should lead with five or fewer headline numbers against prior periods and targets, agree CAC definitions with the CFO, and show three-quarter trends.
“A single data point invites debate. A three-quarter trend tells a story that is much harder to dismiss.”
Eightx proposes a 30 minute Monday review of nine KPIs, led by cash balance and the lowest week of a 13-week cash forecast. Its claim that this catches problems weeks earlier gives no panel size or method.
“Nine KPIs, reviewed every Monday in 30 minutes, replace the reactive dashboard habit”
EightX's board deck covers P&L against plan, 13-week cash, unit economics, channel MER and cohort LTV. In one example, splitting new-customer MER from blended ended a quarter of debate.
Admetrics, an analytics vendor, suggests a one-screen executive view of MER, net revenue, contribution margin, blended CAC, payback and LTV, an operator view below it, and one system of record for orders.
“Create an executive view that fits on one screen. Then add an operator view that explains the drivers.”
PipelineOn, which sells software to contractors, recommends a free Looker Studio dashboard of 7 KPIs, from cost per lead to booked jobs, reviewed 30 minutes every Monday. Paid connectors typically add $50 to $80 a month.
“The job-level source tag is the key - if your CSR is not capturing “how did you hear about us?” with a controlled vocabulary, the attribution chain breaks here.”
Eightx, a CFO firm, says DTC brands under $5M in annual sales need no paid attribution tool: platform ROAS reconciled in a spreadsheet is the default. The real cost of any tool is 2 to 6 weeks of tracking cleanup.
“The default DTC stack at every revenue band is platform-native ROAS reconciled in a spreadsheet, not a paid tool.”
Improvado, a dashboard software vendor, says a CMO dashboard should be scannable in under 60 seconds, with five to seven summary metrics each shown against trend and target. Its metrics lean B2B.
“If you can't tie a metric to a decision, don't include it.”
Common Thread Collective reads its dashboard from the top down: business metrics such as revenue, contribution margin, ad spend and MER first, then customer metrics, then incremental return by channel.
“The hierarchy has three tiers, and you always start at the top”
1ClickReport, a reporting tool vendor, says executives should see 5 to 8 primary KPIs, led by marketing-sourced revenue or blended ROAS, each with a period comparison, a target and a trend.
“If an executive has to scroll to understand performance, you've already lost them.”
Keen, a mix modeling vendor, says executive dashboards should show 5 to 7 headline metrics at most, against goals and prior periods, with commentary. CFOs need financial summaries, marketers operational data.
“Extreme simplicity with 5-7 headline metrics maximum”
Futureproof, which sells ecommerce bookkeeping, says a financial dashboard should show whether you acquire profitably, retain value and make cash. Drop metrics that change no decision, and review weekly.
“If a metric does not change a decision, it does not belong on the primary view.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer