How broad should targeting be on TikTok now?
Our answer
Keep TikTok targeting broad. In Smart+, set only location, any legally required minimum age, language and recent buyer exclusions. In manual ad groups, aim for 80% or more of a country's users and narrow only for a real limit.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 6 TikTok rules
- 1 dataset, 6 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 17 statements
- TS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentTikTok tells advertisers to set only essential targeting limits and to test any narrower strategy against broad. By its own figure, fairly broad audiences get 15% lower cost per action on average.
Those who run TikTok accounts start broad. Jetfuel Agency sets location, excludes past buyers and stacks no interest filters. Segwise (creative analytics software maker) warns that locking too many segments reduces Smart+ learning.
A weak broad campaign usually needs better creative, not tighter targeting (Mega Digital, TikTok ads agency). Influee warns that over-targeting raises cost per thousand impressions (CPM) and slows delivery.
Our judgment
- In Smart+, set only Audience controls and leave audience suggestions empty at first. TikTok treats controls as hard limits and suggestions as guidance it can expand past.
- Keep any manual interest targeting to 2 or 3 categories with Smart Targeting on. This follows Influee's cap, Jetfuel Agency's advice not to stack interest filters and TikTok's advice to enable Smart Targeting with interests.
- Exclude recent buyers from prospecting. Jetfuel Agency excludes converted customers, Common Thread Collective sets audience exclusion guardrails and Influee advises excluding past purchasers.
- Treat ad groups split by audience, as Stackmatix (paid media agency) builds them, as one agency's view. TikTok, Segwise and Mega Digital warn that narrow or fragmented audiences slow learning.
- A local service business narrows only by location. Choose the areas you serve rather than excluding others, because TikTok cannot exclude locations and warns that small areas cut delivery.
Our judgment, built from TikTok, Influee, Jetfuel Agency, Common Thread Collective, Stackmatix, Segwise, Mega Digital and Web Tonic: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
17 statements from 10 sourcesAdManage.ai, which sells TikTok ad launching software, says to start TikTok campaigns with broad targeting and use lookalikes and retargeting only as overlays. It shows no data.
“Use lookalikes and retargeting as overlays, not as your entire acquisition strategy.”
Mega Digital, which sells TikTok ad management, says broad targeting lets creative filter the audience, so poor results usually point to the creative. It prefers fewer, larger ad groups and audiences over 5 million.
“If a Broad campaign underperforms, the issue is likely the creative asset rather than the targeting setting”
Web Tonic, a paid media seller, advises restoration companies on TikTok to target by zip code, DMA or radius, using 25 to 50 mile radii and excluding zip codes outside their service territory. No data given.
“exclude zip codes outside your actual service territory to control waste.”
Common Thread Collective, which sells ad buying, says TikTok merged manual and Smart+ setup into one flow, and suggests full automation for budget and placements but partial control of targeting and creative.
“Pay particular attention to the creative module setting if your brand has specific creative control requirements, as the default may have moved to full automation.”
TikTok does not allow excluding locations or zip codes, allows up to 3,000 locations per ad group, and warns small areas cut delivery and may raise CPA.
“TikTok does not support the exclusion of locations or zip codes.”
Measured's incrementality data on $43M of enterprise consumer brands' TikTok spend found Smart+ and GMV Max beat standard setups at several brands, while awareness and consideration buys indexed near zero.
“conversion-objective prospecting dramatically out-performed awareness and consideration buys of the same platform, often by 5x to 10x.”
Stackmatix, which manages TikTok ads, recommends one campaign per objective, 3 to 5 ad groups split by audience and 3 to 5 creatives in each, and never mixing prospecting and retargeting. It shows no results.
“never mix prospecting and retargeting in a single campaign.”
Stackmatix, an agency selling TikTok management, calls Smart+ a strong default with a working pixel and some conversions, but weaker when you need precise audience control. Its exclusion point is dated.
“Many startups run Smart+ for discovery and manual campaigns for controlled retargeting side by side.”
TikTok says Audience Controls set account-wide targeting limits, such as age, once for all new ads, including Smart+, and work with every objective except Branded Mission and TikTok Shop.
“Audience Controls allow you to set targeting constraints due to compliance or business availability to all new ads in your account.”
Influee, which sells UGC content, says over-targeting on TikTok works against you: cap manual interests at 2-3 categories, leave age broad, and aim for an audience of 1M to 20M. No data shown.
“Below 500K is too narrow, so CPM runs high and delivery gets choppy.”
Jetfuel, an agency, tells food and beverage brands on TikTok to use broad audiences, Spark Ads on proven organic posts, at least $100 a day for new conversion campaigns, and budget raises of 15-20% every 3-4 days.
“For new conversion campaigns, don't drop below $100/day if you want the algorithm to exit the learning phase within 5-7 days.”
TikTok's upgraded Smart+ uses automatic targeting by default. Audience controls such as location, minimum age and exclusions are hard limits, while suggestions like interests only guide it.
“By default, TikTok will use automatic targeting to identify and optimize toward the best-performing audience with minimal input from you.”
Segwise, which sells creative analytics, suggests a 7 to 14 day hybrid TikTok Smart+ test with 4 to 6 creatives and no major edits for 7 days, warning that locking too many segments hurts learning. No data.
“Locking too many segments reduces Smart+ learning efficiency, as managers risk overconstraining.”
TikTok says Smart+ campaigns should start with a broad audience, and narrow targeting can make ad groups struggle to exit the learning phase. Use it only for a specific need or after testing.
“Start with a broad audience.”
TikTok says fairly broad audiences, over 80% of a country's users, tend to outperform others by a wide margin, with about 15% lower CPA and 20% higher conversion rates. TikTok grades itself; no method given.
“tend to outperform all others by a wide margin.”
TikTok says Smart Targeting can deliver beyond your chosen interest and audience settings when that likely helps, but keeps age, gender and location. It claims lower CPA without figures.
“Smart Targeting will not affect other targeting variables you have selected, such as age, gender, or location.”
TikTok advises broad targeting with only essential limits, reaching audiences of 80% or more of a country's users, and says to check whether advanced targeting actually beats it.
“While advanced targeting strategies exist, validate if they outperform broad targeting.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer