How should agencies report results to us?
Our answer
Make agencies report into your numbers. Lead with store or CRM revenue, total sales divided by total ad spend (MER) and new-customer acquisition cost with fees. Show platform results beside yours with the gap explained, and keep admin access.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 official rules
- 1 dataset, 9 practitioners, 10 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 19 sources
- 23 statements
G
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentBusiness totals belong at the top. Balistro, a media and measurement agency, runs its weekly report on MER, profit on ad spend, blended acquisition cost and the split of new and repeat revenue. It pulls them from the store rather than the ad platforms.
Platform numbers need a check beside them. ATTN Agency wants platform attribution compared with your own analytics and the gap explained. It argues that reports showing only platform numbers, or avoiding incrementality, are red flags.
The agency should not grade its own work. Cody Plofker, a former beauty brand CEO, never lets anyone create their own homework. Stackmatix, a paid media agency, calls reporting only through the agency's own dashboard a red flag.
Our judgment
We count the agency's own fees in the acquisition cost its report shows. That applies Eightx's fully loaded measure, which includes agency or team costs, to agency reporting. We let your own lift tests, not the agency's attribution, settle budget between channels. That joins Cody Plofker's rule with the requests from ATTN Agency and M+C Saatchi Performance for incrementality read-outs. And we ask for a short weekly read and a fuller monthly review, joining Balistro's weekly six-metric report and monthly deep dive with ATTN Agency's monthly report.
Our judgment, built from Eightx, Cody Plofker, ATTN Agency, M+C Saatchi Performance and Balistro: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
23 statements from 19 sourcesGoogle Ads offers Email-only, Billing, Read-only, Standard and Admin access levels, and only Admin can grant access or unlink manager accounts. Having a single admin risks losing access to tags.
“If your account has only one administrator, you may lose access to your tags if that user becomes unavailable.”
Google says client accounts linked to a manager account keep working as usual, and users with admin access can unlink from the manager account at any time.
“But users with administrative access to those accounts can terminate the relationship with the manager account at any time by unlinking their account from the manager account.”
Josh Nelson, an agency coach, tells agencies to present each monthly report on a 20 to 30 minute call, leading with two or three numbers tied to the client's business, such as booked jobs and cost per lead.
“Don't just send the report. Present it.”
Meta says an ad account can sit in only one business portfolio, and adding an existing one may move it there permanently; an agency can instead request shared access, leaving the account with the client.
“Adding an existing ad account to a business portfolio may permanently move it into the portfolio, meaning it can't be deleted or transferred to another portfolio.”
Sellforte, which sells incrementality testing, says adoption needs clear roles: analytics owns the evidence, marketing decides, finance sets the hurdle and channel owners execute. It offers no data.
“Without those roles, an iROAS dashboard can become one more report that nobody uses.”
Stackmatix says the brand should own its Business Manager, pixels, audiences and domains, with the agency added as a partner, and flags assets set up under the agency's own account.
“The startup keeps every account, pixel, and audience; the agency operates them under roles you control.”
Cody Plofker's first independent check on TV is the post-purchase survey, scaled up by the response rate (if half of buyers answer, double it), then compared with other attribution models.
“never allow anyone to create their own homework”
Silverback Strategies, an agency, says to ask an agency how it proves your spend caused sales, expecting holdout or geo tests, and to treat reliance on platform-reported ROAS as a red flag.
“how do you know our spend caused these sales rather than just took credit for them?”
Balistro, an agency, says a weekly report needs six metrics shown the same way every week: MER, POAS, blended CAC, new versus repeat revenue, top 3 creatives and a one-line narrative.
“Weekly reports answer "are we on track," monthly reviews answer "why, and what's the plan."”
M+C Saatchi Performance, an agency, says a capable agency runs geo holdouts or similar tests and shows the read-out, shares KPI definitions and dashboards, and flags weak campaigns before being asked.
“Agencies that never test incrementality end up defending channels that were already going to convert.”
Eightx, a CFO firm, says fully loaded CAC, counting creative, agency, influencer and discount costs, runs 40 to 80% above paid-media CAC. For one fashion client, $45 became $78.
“Anything you spent to win that customer counts.”
Opascope, an agency, says that across 200+ audited accounts 15 to 25% of non-brand spend was usually recoverable in 90 days, and a working creative program gets 5 to 7% winners. Its method is not stated.
“A 1 to 2% hit rate across a full quarter is a failing program.”
The host of Meta Ads: Under the Hood says an agency that reads only the Meta ads dashboard, without opening Shopify or the email platform, sees just the tip of the iceberg.
“then you are literally just looking at the tip of the iceberg”
MarketerHire, which sells freelance marketers, says a good DTC agency names its people and puts 30/60/90-day success metrics in writing, on a 90-day term then month-to-month. It gives no data.
“Anyone insisting on a 12-month minimum is selling themselves, not their work.”
Flighted, an agency, says the brand should own its ad account, pixel and data and keep full admin access. When moving in-house, budget for 2-3 months of weaker results while the new team ramps up.
“You own your ad account, pixel, and historical data. Full stop.”
Eightx, a CFO firm, says a marketing analyst usually appears at $15M to $20M in annual revenue; before that the head of growth runs the spreadsheets. Analytics should move in-house by $15M to $25M.
“Marketing analytics or ops usually appears at $15 to $20M, before that it's the head of growth running spreadsheets at 11pm.”
Elevarus, an agency, says incrementality read-outs should lead with the dollars to move (say $400K attributed, $180K incremental, $220K to move), and contracts should settle up front what an inconclusive test means.
“Lead with the dollar reallocation, not the lift ratio”
Admetrics, an analytics vendor, suggests daily pacing checks, weekly budget moves comparing platform and blended results, and monthly or quarterly marginal ROAS and LTV. No data.
“Weekly is the sweet spot for most teams. It balances signal and noise, especially when attribution drifts.”
Loftie, a CTC client, calls contribution margin after product, fulfillment and Meta spend its key business metric, and CTC puts it at the top of client dashboards.
“the key business metric”
Common Thread Collective reports to clients through its Statlas platform, fed by Northbeam attribution. Gains it cites for beta brands (283%, 175%, 550%) are attributed revenue and transactions, not tested lift.
Eightx says use platform ROAS for channel tactics, MER for business efficiency and blended CAC for scaling against a 3:1 LTV to CAC target, with a 20 to 25% margin after marketing as the limit.
“Use all three together, with CM3 (contribution margin after variable marketing) of 20 to 25% as the north-star constraint.”
ATTN Agency says good agency reports lead with incremental revenue, CAC by channel and a few recommendations, and compare platform and analytics numbers. Reports built on reach, clicks or CPMs are a red flag.
“Missing from those 47 slides: actual revenue, customer acquisition cost, or profitability impact.”
In a case study from Wicked Reports, an attribution seller, Tier 11 made new-customer cost the executive KPI for one pet brand. That cost fell from $193 to $128 and new customers rose 25% on 2.7% more spend.
“nCAC and New Customer Media Efficiency Ratio (nMER) became the north star metrics”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer