Which Google recommendations and auto-applied changes should we accept or turn off?
Our answer
Turn off auto-apply and review the Recommendations page about weekly. Apply repairs, tracking fixes, assets and negatives, and dismiss budget, broad match and expansion suggestions or test them first. Recheck Google's default-on automations monthly.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 12 Google rules
- 9 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 12 sources
- 23 statements
- G
VMPA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAuto-apply can widen your spend without asking. Google's auto-apply list covers target changes, broad match keywords, Search partners and Display expansion. Applied changes show in Change history and can be undone within 30 days, and dismissals last 28 or 60 days.
Practitioners turn it off and recheck it (Verde Media, PPC Rebels, Dotidot). PACE Ads keeps it only for low-risk fixes and calls a 70 to 80% score good.
Google raises optimization score for dismissals too and asks its Partner agencies for an optimization score of 70%. It also keeps switching on new defaults. Google opted accounts into automated promotions from October 12, 2026 (PPC Land).
Our judgment
- Turn auto-apply off and keep it off. Its list includes the kind of reach and match widening that Verde Media, PPC Rebels, Dotidot and PACE Ads treat as items to review rather than accept. PACE Ads' exception for low-risk items, such as removing redundant keywords, is reasonable only if you read Google's weekly auto-apply email.
- Review the Recommendations page about weekly, sorting each suggestion into apply, dismiss or experiment. Apply repairs, conversion tracking fixes, missing sitelinks and callouts and negatives from poor search terms. Dismiss raise-budget, broad match, new keyword, Search partners, Display and targeting expansion suggestions with a reason unless they fit a plan you already have, and send bid strategy, target or budget ideas through Save as experiment (Match types and negative keywords and Setting up and reading a Google Ads experiment).
- Treat optimization score as a to-do list, not a goal. Google defines it as an estimate of how the account is set up and asks 70% only of agencies holding its Partner badge. An agency that reports the score should also report what it dismissed and why.
- Check the History tab and Change history, including in any manager account. They show who turned auto-apply on and what it changed, and you can undo unwanted changes within Google's window.
- Recheck auto-apply and Google's default-on automations at least monthly, as Verde Media and Dotidot advise (PPC Rebels says quarterly). Google keeps adding defaults: the AI Max upgrade on Search, sourced videos and, from December 4, 2026, image extraction in new Performance Max campaigns, automated promotions, experiment auto-apply and Customer Match lists added to Smart Bidding. This holds at every monthly Google spend, since these are account settings and no source ties its advice to spend. A local business with location assets has one more default to check, automated promotions.
Our judgment, built from Google, Verde Media, PPC Rebels, Dotidot, PACE Ads, PPC Land and Common Thread Collective: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
23 statements from 12 sourcesChris Shaver says never to turn on Google Ads auto-apply recommendations, which can switch on things like search partners and push spend toward low-quality traffic.
“There is absolutely no reason for you to turn that on.”
Jyll Saskin Gales says to turn off Google's auto-apply recommendations, citing one account whose exact match keywords were switched to broad match. One example, no figures.
“You want auto-apply recommendations turned off”
Google's help page says auto-applied recommendations run regularly at account level, do not raise budget, and include changes such as CPA and ROAS targets and broad match keywords. It reports no results.
“Auto-applying recommendations won't increase your budget”
Google's help page on auto-apply recommendations: turn it on from the Recommendations page; the change history shows who enrolled the account and when. A product rule, not a result.
“You can confirm who enrolled your account, and when, through the account’s change history”
Google says you can test bid or budget recommendations as an experiment before applying them, undo an applied one within 30 days, and dismiss one for 28 or 60 days, after which it may return.
“Select Save as experiment to find the impact of a recommendation before applying it to your entire campaign.”
Google says optimization score is an estimate of how well a Google Ads account is set to perform, from 0 to 100%, and that applying its recommendations can help performance. It gives no figures.
“Optimization score is an estimate of how well your Google Ads account is set to perform.”
Google says Partner badge agencies need a minimum 70% optimization score on their manager account. They need not apply every recommendation or reach 100%, and can dismiss ones that do not fit.
“You are not required to adopt all recommendations or achieve a 100% optimization score for the new Google Partner badge requirements.”
Google pulls promotions from your landing pages and attaches them to eligible Search and Performance Max campaigns with location assets. Each serves under 24 hours; you can switch it off in account settings.
“Make sure to keep your website's promotional details up to date, or manually upload specific promotions if you require exact control over what is shown.”
Google auto-creates account-level assets such as sitelinks, callouts and images when it predicts better results, and they may show instead of yours. You can review them and turn each type off.
“may show alongside or instead of manually created callouts”
WordStream's Michelle Morgan shows an account hitting all its goals at a 67% optimization score, where the top recommendation, AI Max, had tested poorly. One account.
“The optimization score is only 67% despite hitting all of our business goals”
Google recommends running a Google Ads experiment for 2 to 3 weeks, uses an 80% confidence interval by default, and auto-applies a winning trial to 100% of traffic unless you turn that off.
“We recommend allowing your experiment to run for 2 to 3 weeks to gather data.”
Google turns on sourced videos by default in Performance Max, adding up to 10 videos per asset group found on social platforms, your landing page or YouTube channel. You can switch it off under Asset optimization.
“Sourced videos are enabled by default for all new campaigns.”
Google says Smart Bidding campaigns automatically use all Customer Match lists, manual bidding ignores them, and memberships expire after 540 days unless at least 100 members are added or updated.
“Customer Match memberships expire after 540 days. To keep a list eligible, ensure at least 100 members are added or updated within that window.”
Google turns AI Max on by default for new Search campaigns. Its search term matching and URL expansion need conversion-based Smart Bidding, and text guidelines and URL exclusions let you limit it.
“New Search campaigns have the AI Max feature turned on by default.”
Google will turn on image extraction by default for new Performance Max campaigns from December 4, 2026, even if dynamic images are off for the account. Advertisers who don't want it must opt out per campaign.
“Existing Performance Max campaigns will retain their current configurations”
PPC Land reports Google Ads began auto-adding discount offers from advertiser sites to Search and Performance Max campaigns on October 12, 2026, with one account-level opt-out and seven days' notice.
“Google Ads will begin pulling discount offers from advertiser sites and attaching them to campaigns on October 12, 2026”
Julie Bacchini reports a new Google Ads campaign notice asking advertisers to dismiss recommendations again, and says Google is getting pushier on recommendations. No recommendation types are named and no data is given.
“Google is getting pushier on recommendations”
Common Thread Collective, an agency, lists steps after Google's September 2026 AI Max migration, such as reviewing search terms. It relays Google's claim of 7% more conversions on average.
“full AI Max suite averages 7% more conversions or conversion value at similar CPA or ROAS”
PPC Rebels, which rents agency ad accounts, says to turn off Google's auto-apply recommendations in every account, check at manager level each quarter, and aim for a 70 to 85% optimization score.
“The practical rule is blunt: turn auto-apply off entirely in every working account.”
PACE Ads, which sells ad management software, calls a 70 to 80% optimization score good: accept repairs, assets and tracking fixes, dismiss budget raises and broad match. It warns auto-apply skips review.
“auto-apply removes the review step that prevents costly mistakes.”
Verde Media, which sells Google Ads management to small local firms, says turn off all auto-apply recommendations, accept tracking and asset fixes, and mostly ignore Display and Performance Max suggestions.
“dismissing a recommendation gives you the exact same score boost as applying it.”
Dotidot, which sells PPC automation tools, calls Google's auto-applied recommendations the most dangerous feature, advises a monthly review, and says try any recommendation on one campaign for 14 to 30 days first.
“Auto-applied recommendations are perhaps the most dangerous feature in the Recommendations tab.”
Anthony Higman calls Google's auto-apply recommendations and automated assets silent killers, because they change a lot in your account without you noticing.
“these are the big ones that like are silent killers”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer