How should we get reviews on Amazon within the rules?
Our answer
Ask every buyer once through Amazon's own review request and enroll each new product in Vine before launch while it has under 30 reviews. Test the new Review Requests ads with a fixed budget. Never offer anything for a review.
- Confidence
- High
- Strongest proof
- 9 Amazon rules
- 5 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 16 statements
- A
UF
CMMAEVS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAmazon allows one neutral request per order, through its own feature. It bans rewards, inserts and asking only happy buyers, and it penalizes sellers for their agencies' breaches. In the US, the Federal Trade Commission's rule bars fake reviews.
Vine gets a new product up to 30 reviews before or at launch. It costs $0, $75 or $200 per parent product, billed only after a first review. Amazon claims a 30% average sales lift, its own figure.
Most agencies ask every buyer and use Vine early. Canopy Management, My Amazon Guy and Epinium ask every buyer, and Canopy Management uses Vine at launch and Review Requests after. Velocity Sellers (Amazon management agency) waits for 5 to 10 organic reviews first.
Our judgment
Run all three of Amazon's review routes in sequence. Use the request button on every order, Vine at launch while under 30 reviews, and Review Requests after that, as Canopy Management, My Amazon Guy and Amazon's own pages lay out. Enroll in Vine before launch rather than waiting for organic reviews as Velocity Sellers does, but only once the product and listing are ready. Amazon recommends enrolling ahead of launch, and Eva and Velocity Sellers warn that Vine reviewers expose flaws. Treat Review Requests as a fixed-budget test judged on cost per new rating. Amazon has not published billing, and its threefold figure comes from a short before and after beta, as Canopy Management and PPC Land note.
Our judgment, built from Canopy Management, My Amazon Guy, Amazon, Eva, Velocity Sellers and PPC Land: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
16 statements from 8 sourcesAmazon allows one neutral review or feedback request per customer per order, ideally with Request a Review, and bans incentives, asking for a rating, or steering unhappy buyers away from reviewing.
“Feedback can be requested once per customer per order.”
Amazon bans offering any reward for reviews, including through review services or package inserts, and holds sellers responsible for their agencies. Penalties include permanent loss of selling rights.
“Amazon has a zero-tolerance policy towards any customer reviews violations.”
The FTC says incentives for reviews are allowed if they don't require a particular sentiment, but must be disclosed; ordering reviews so negative ones are hard to find could be deceptive.
“The rule does not prohibit giving incentives for reviews, as long as there isn’t an express or implied requirement that the reviews have to express a particular sentiment.”
Amazon Vine takes products with fewer than 30 reviews, gives up to 30 Vine reviews per parent ASIN, allows one enrollment per ASIN ever, and runs 90 days. Billing starts after the first Vine review.
“You can enroll an ASIN in Vine only once in its lifetime”
Amazon's US Vine fee is charged once per parent product: $0 for 1 to 2 units, $75 for 3 to 10 and $200 for 11 to 30, whatever the number of reviews. Some sources report different fees.
“The fee charged does not depend on the number of units claimed by reviewers or number of reviews received.”
Amazon recommends enrolling in Vine with stock in its warehouses at least three weeks before launch. Existing products qualify with under 30 reviews, and you pay nothing if no review arrives in 90 days.
“For best results, we recommend enrolling in Vine and having your inventory available in our fulfillment network at least three weeks before your planned launch date.”
Amazon says Vine gets new products up to 30 reviews from Vine Voices who try them free, and claims a 30% average sales boost. It needs Brand Registry and FBA offers; new registrants get a $200 credit.
“New sellers who enroll a brand in Amazon Brand Registry get a $200 credit for Amazon Vine.”
Canopy Management, an Amazon agency, says run Request a Review on every order, Vine at launch, and the new Review Requests ad type after that as a four-week test with a set budget. No data.
“A free product, a discount, or a refund in exchange for a review is still off limits.”
My Amazon Guy, an Amazon agency, says to send one Request a Review per eligible order 5 to 30 days after delivery, ask every buyer, and use Vine only before a product has 30 reviews.
“A new listing needs its first reviews, while a big listing needs its complaints answered.”
PPC Land says Amazon's 3x figure for its paid review-request ads comes from a 19-day closed beta compared with each product's own earlier rate, not a control group, and pricing is not disclosed.
“company-supplied data from a closed beta lasting 19 days”
PPC Land says Amazon Vine's top tier, $200 for 30 units, is under $7 per review before product cost, and Amazon's 30% sales claim is unaudited. A report of higher fees conflicts with Amazon's own page.
“Amazon claims Vine raises sales by an average of 30%, a figure it attributes to internal data that has not been independently audited.”
Amazon's Review Requests ads invite recent buyers to review products with fewer than 1,000 ratings, in US open beta from late October 2026. Amazon claims its June beta tripled weekly reviews.
“Early test results show that products received three times as many ratings and reviews per week compared to before the test”
Eva, an Amazon agency, says Vine should not cover for a weak product, and advises not defaulting to the top tier: up to 2 units checks signal, 3 to 10 is a controlled launch, 11 to 30 a full push.
“Do not use review acquisition to compensate for an unclear, defective, or poorly positioned product.”
Velocity Sellers, an Amazon agency, says from its 400+ Vine enrollments that Vine is net-negative for about 35% of brands. It advises waiting for 5 to 10 organic reviews of 4.3+ and using 30 units.
“Amazon Vine is net-negative for roughly 35% of the brands that use it.”
Epinium, which sells Amazon software, says review gating breaks Amazon policy, the request button sends a fixed template, day 15 beats day 2 for asking, and inserts can't tie any benefit to a review.
“Asking on day 15 is when the user has formed a genuine opinion about the product’s performance, durability, or ease of use.”
The FTC's review rule, in force since October 2024, bans writing, creating or selling reviews or testimonials that misrepresent that the reviewer exists, used the product, or what their experience was.
“for a business to write, create, or sell a consumer review, consumer testimonial, or celebrity testimonial that materially misrepresents”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer