How should we compare Amazon ad results with Meta and Google?
Our answer
Don't rank Amazon, Meta and Google on the ROAS each one reports. Compare them on margin after each channel's costs, with branded spend split out. Move budget only on incremental results read across your site and Amazon together.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 Amazon rules
- 1 dataset, 5 practitioners, 5 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 14 sources
- 15 statements
- A
M
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentEach platform counts sales its own way. Meta credits 1 or 7 days after a click and 1 day after a view. Google Ads defaults to 30 days after a click. Sponsored Products in Seller Central use 7 days after a click.
Added together, platform figures count one sale several times, because every platform claims the same conversion under its own window (Stackmatix). Comparing a 14-day view figure with a 7-day click figure only ranks measurement policies (Osmos).
Reported figures miss in both directions. Neato's audits put branded ROAS at 6 to 15 times reported against 1 to 3 times incremental. Haus found YouTube drove about 2.3 times the site sales Google Ads reported.
Our judgment
Put every channel on contribution after its own costs before comparing, because the reported returns use different windows and view rules and can each claim the same sale. Split branded and retargeting spend out of each channel's figures first, since Neato's audits find branded ROAS reported far above its incremental return. Move budget only on incremental reads that count sales on your site and Amazon together. Amazon puts about 20% of sales value after its window, so reported figures miss in both directions.
Our judgment, built from Meta, Google, Amazon, Osmos, Stack Influence, Stackmatix, FiveX, Neato, Haus, Digiday and Northbeam: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 14 sourcesMeta says results from ad sets using different attribution models can't be compared, and its standard window counts conversions 1 or 7 days after a click and 1 day after a view.
“comparing across different attribution models will lead to inaccurate conclusions.”
Amazon's Sponsored Brands video ads need Brand Registry, have no minimum spend (from $10), and take 9:16 or 16:9 video. Amazon advises 15 to 30 seconds, the product in the first two seconds, and captions.
“There is no minimum spend requirement, so you can start and test campaigns with any budget, starting as low as $10.”
Google's default conversion windows are 30 days for clicks, 3 days for engaged views and 1 day for views. It recommends at least 7 days for clicks, and changes apply only going forward.
“Note that windows of at least 7 days are recommended, because they provide a richer set of conversion data.”
Stack Influence advises checking that Walmart Sponsored Products items are in stock and winning the Buy Box before raising bids, and setting bids from your own margin, not suggested bids.
“Confirm that each advertised item is published, in stock, and winning the Buy Box before increasing bids.”
Northbeam, which sells measurement, says measure Amazon with correlation and incrementality against a baseline set before launch, and don't set Amazon budget from platform ROAS. No data shown.
“Don't allocate Amazon budget just by looking at platform ROAS.”
Haus says its geo tests found YouTube drove about 2.3x the DTC sales Google Ads reports, and about 24% of lift came after the flight ended. Test and brand counts are not given.
“one test is a read, not a verdict.”
Osmos, which sells retail media software, says to compare ROAS only on the same category, ad type, attribution window and sales rules, and to run an incrementality test on at least one campaign per network.
“Comparing a 14-day view-through figure with a 7-day click-only figure ranks the two networks' measurement policies.”
Amazon estimates about a fifth of a brand's Amazon sales value arrives after the usual 7 to 30 day attribution window, from 2 million June campaigns. Some agencies say its projected TV uplift does not show up.
“roughly 20% of the sales value for a brand shows up over time and isn't captured in that immediate attribution window”
Priceva, citing others, says Walmart ad clicks cost less than Amazon's but Walmart's 14-day window can make ROAS look 10 to 25% higher. One seller reported an 80% paid share of Walmart sales.
“Walmart Connect reporting commonly uses a 14-day attribution window, while Amazon Sponsored Products uses a 7-day click attribution window for Seller Central advertisers.”
Stackmatix, a paid media agency, says treat Reddit's reported conversions as an upper bound and test with a 10 to 20% audience holdout or a two-week regional pause. Under about 30 events a week, optimize higher up.
“Treat Reddit's attributed conversions as an upper bound, not a ledger.”
FiveX, which sells marketplace ad software, says retail media dashboards show attribution, not whether sales would have happened anyway, and to check total SKU revenue and margin when spend changes.
“Incrementality is only useful when connected to contribution margin.”
Darkroom, an Amazon agency, describes one client launch (DedCool, 90 products) run with video and prospecting first. It targets a new-to-brand order rate above 60% on awareness. No results are given.
“Judging all three against one blended ACoS is the most common allocation error we see in audits.”
Neato, an Amazon seller, says branded Amazon ROAS typically reports 6 to 15x but true incremental return lands nearer 1 to 3x, from its audits with no method. It suggests a two-week pause test against a control.
“Your Amazon Ads ROAS reports first-purchase revenue. It doesn't report lifetime customer value.”
Eightx, compiling agency benchmarks, calls ad spend of 10-15% of total Amazon revenue (TACOS) healthy, 25 to 40% normal at launch, and says break-even TACOS equals your margin before ads.
“Break-even TACOS equals your pre-ad gross margin.”
Amazon moved Sponsored Brands, vCPM Sponsored Display and in-store DSP ads to a view-crediting attribution model with a shorter window on January 1, 2026. Click-based attribution is unchanged.
“Conversion reporting for all other campaign types and inventory types remains unchanged. Click-based attribution remains unchanged.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer