Should we build buying guides, and how should they link to products?
Our answer
Build them where your buyers compare options. Have someone who used the products write them, with pros, cons and a reason for each pick, and link each pick to its product page.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 4 official rules, 1 dataset, 2 practitioners, 5 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 13 statements
- G
SC1RDMCS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentGoogle allows guides from merchants who know the products. Its review guidance lets a merchant's expert staff guide shoppers between competing products. It asks for first-hand evidence, benefits and drawbacks, and a reason for any best pick.
Guides should send shoppers straight to what they recommend. Shopify, Steve Chou (store owner and course seller) and 1Digital all link guides directly to the products they cover. Google says descriptive internal links help show which pages matter.
Expect fewer clicks from comparison searches, since AI Overviews appear on most of them. Semrush found AI Overviews on 85.11% of ecommerce comparison searches. In a randomized test, Saharsh Agarwal and Ananya Sen (university researchers) measured a 39.8% fall in organic clicks where one appeared.
Our judgment
- Build guides where buyers compare before choosing, and give each pick a first-hand reason. This follows Google's review guidance and 1Digital's view that buying guides catch searches from shoppers deciding which product to get.
- Link each pick to its product page from the sentence that recommends it. Link the guide to its collection, and link to the guide from that collection and its main products. This follows Google's link text and internal link guidance, Shopify's guide and Steve Chou's gift guides.
- Compare honestly rather than rank your own product first with no evidence. Lily Ray found self-ranking brands left out of most Google AI answers citing them, while Kevin Indig and Scrunch saw gains (all reported by PPC Land). Google asks for first-hand reasons for any best pick.
- Judge guides on the sales they assist, not clicks alone. AI Overviews show on most of these searches (Semrush) and cut organic clicks where they appear (Agarwal and Sen).
Our judgment, built from Google, 1Digital, Shopify, Steve Chou, PPC Land, Semrush and Saharsh Agarwal and Ananya Sen: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
13 statements from 9 sourcesSemrush, which sells SEO tools, says AI Overviews showed on 88% of 400 tracked commercial keywords in August 2026, up from 45.75% a year earlier; ecommerce queries rose from 32.62% to 85.11%, on desktop.
“Across the 400 commercial modifier keywords we tracked, AI Overview coverage reached 88% in August 2026, up from 45.75% in September 2025.”
A University of Toronto study of 158,099 AI answers found ChatGPT consults 26 pages on average and cites 3, and at equal rank cites brand pages more (x1.71) than lists, comparisons or Reddit threads.
“at equal rank, concise pages from the original source win over roundups and forums.”
Lily Ray found Google's AI Overviews cite 38% fewer vendor-written best-of lists than in June, and the self-ranking brand was left out 83% of the time. One consultant's small software sample.
“These are a consultant's own measurements, on a small sample from one vertical and one AI surface.”
PPC Land reports a GetCited study of 3,334 product questions finding 25.4% of AI answer citations lead to pages with a disclosed commercial interest. GetCited sells article placements.
“The central figure is that 25.4% of English citations lead to a page carrying a disclosed commercial interest.”
A randomized field test of 1,000+ Chrome users found AI Overviews cut organic clicks to other sites by 39.8% and raised no-click searches by 34.5%, with no change in sponsored clicks. Not peer reviewed.
“we found no corresponding change in clicks on sponsored links or in search frequency.”
1Digital, an ecommerce SEO agency, says blog posts build awareness but rarely close sales, while buying guides, comparison pages and category pages reach shoppers close to buying.
“The takeaway is blunt: blog posts build awareness, but they rarely close sales on their own.”
Shopify's SEO lead advises working in stages: fix on-page SEO for top product pages, then internal links, then backlink outreach, starting with pages that already get traffic or sales.
“backlinks work best after your own pages are useful and easy to navigate.”
Steve Chou says his store's blog traffic rose about 40% while his standalone blog fell about 40%, and that store blogs work when posts answer a real question and link to products. One operator's own sites.
“Blogging only makes sense today if your site actually sells something.”
Rocks Digital, which sells SEO writing, says service pages serve people ready to buy, while supporting blog posts send traffic to them and earn more shares and links. It shows no data.
“People share and link to guides or tips more than they do to sales pages.”
Google's guidance for review content says to show evidence of first-hand experience, share measurements, explain what sets a product apart, and say why something is best, focusing on quality over length.
“When recommending something as the best overall or the best for a certain purpose, include why you consider it the best, with first-hand supporting evidence.”
Google's guidance for review content says to cover comparable options, discuss benefits and drawbacks from your own research, focus on key decision factors and link to useful resources.
“Discuss the benefits and drawbacks of something, based on your own original research.”
Google says anchor text should be descriptive and concise, every important page should get at least one internal link, there is no ideal number of links, and keyword stuffing in anchors breaks its spam rules.
“Every page you care about should have a link from at least one other page on your site.”
Google advises linking menus to category pages, categories to subcategories and subcategories to all product pages, since a page with more internal links reads as more important.
“As a general rule, the more links a page has to it within a site, the higher the relative importance of the page to other pages on your site.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer