How should we respond to negative reviews on Amazon?
Our answer
You cannot answer Amazon product reviews or contact reviewers. Report only reviews that break Amazon's rules and fix the faults repeated complaints show. Help buyers only when they message you, and never mention the review.
- Confidence
- High
- Strongest proof
- 7 Amazon rules
- 5 practitioners
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 12 statements
- AUFDSSRG
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentReaching out to unhappy reviewers is closed. Amazon staff confirmed in June 2026 that brand owners can no longer use Brand Customer Reviews to contact buyers who leave 1 to 3 star reviews. You can still reply when customers contact you first.
Pressure on a review breaks the rules. Amazon's policy treats asking a reviewer to change or remove a review, or offering a refund for it, as a violation. Amazon removes only reviews that break its Community Guidelines.
Honest negative reviews stay up, so the useful work is fixing the product or listing cause. Desverto, SalesDuo and GrowEventure all advise this.
Our judgment
We would spend the effort that once went into contacting reviewers on finding and fixing the cause behind repeated complaints. Amazon offers Brand Customer Reviews and Voice of the Customer for this work, and SalesDuo, Desverto and SupplyKick all point to fixing causes. We report only reviews that clearly break a named guideline, because Amazon removes nothing else and Desverto and Reverbico say weak reports are closed and count against you. We treat GrowEventure's suggestion to message the buyer behind a review as out of date, since Amazon says sellers can respond when customers contact them first.
Our judgment, built from Amazon, SalesDuo, Desverto, SupplyKick, Reverbico and GrowEventure: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
12 statements from 7 sourcesAmazon says sellers may answer negative reviews only through Buyer-Seller Messaging and may never ask for a review to be changed or removed, even with a refund; report rule-breaking reviews instead.
“You may not request positive reviews only, ask customers to change or remove reviews (even during returns/replacements), or attempt to influence reviews in any way.”
Amazon's review policy bans asking buyers to change or remove reviews, offering refunds in exchange, or routing negative reviews elsewhere while sending positive ones to Amazon.
“A seller diverts negative reviews to be sent to them or to a different feedback mechanism while positive reviews are sent to Amazon.”
Amazon allows one neutral review or feedback request per customer per order, ideally with Request a Review, and bans incentives, asking for a rating, or steering unhappy buyers away from reviewing.
“Feedback can be requested once per customer per order.”
Amazon's Voice of the Customer tracks the share of orders with a reported product or listing issue across returns, contacts, reviews and claims. Fixes can take several weeks to show in the metrics.
“The NCX rate is the number of orders for which a customer reported a product or listing issue divided by total orders.”
Amazon says to contact buyers who leave negative seller feedback, which they can remove within 60 days, and allows one brief public reply. This covers seller feedback, not product reviews.
“When replying to negative feedback, keep your comments brief and professional.”
SalesDuo, an Amazon agency, notes sellers can't reply publicly to reviews; fix the cause, report only rule-breaking reviews, and never tie a refund to changing a review.
“Never make a refund, replacement, or other solution dependent on the customer changing, deleting, or improving a review.”
GrowEventure, an Amazon agency, says to fix the cause of bad reviews and never ask for a changed rating. Its advice to message reviewers conflicts with Amazon's June 2026 change.
“Amazon removes a review only when it breaks the Community Guidelines.”
SupplyKick, an Amazon agency, says sellers have not been able to reply publicly to product reviews since early 2021, so use repeated complaints to fix listings, such as adding size references.
“One negative review about breakage might be a fluke. Five negative reviews about the same issue signal a real problem.”
Reverbico, a reputation firm, says Amazon doesn't remove reviews for being negative or wrong; off-topic reviews are removed most reliably, and reports should name the broken rule and quote it.
“The report should name the guideline, quote the words that break it, and stop.”
Desverto, an Amazon agency, says Amazon removes reviews only for policy breaches such as off-topic, personal or promotional content, never for being negative, and sellers can't ask buyers to change reviews.
“Amazon review removal only happens for policy violations, not for being negative.”
Amazon staff said in June 2026 that sellers can no longer use Brand Customer Reviews to contact buyers who leave 1 to 3 star reviews, though they can reply when customers reach out first.
“You can still respond when customers contact you first about an issue.”
The FTC's review rule bars using groundless legal threats, physical threats, intimidation or knowingly false public accusations to stop a review or get it removed.
“Cause a review or any portion thereof to be removed”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer