Should we run Amazon in house, with an agency or with a full-service partner?
Our answer
Run Amazon yourself under about $1M a year in sales. From there keep one in-house owner and rent ad and listing specialists, and build a full team above about $15M to $20M. A reseller costs you price control.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 Amazon rule
- 1 practitioner, 8 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 10 statements
- A
AYSPJEMA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentDoing it yourself costs the least cash. SalesDuo (Amazon agency) puts that at about $500,000 a year in Amazon sales, with an agency competitive near $1 million. Andrew Youderian (ecommerce community founder) advises bringing ads in house under $500K a year in ad spend.
One in-house owner plus a specialist agency fits the middle, advise PPC Jumpstart (Amazon ads agency) and Evolve Media (ecommerce marketing agency). PPC Jumpstart puts full in-house teams above about $15 to $20M, and Evolve Media puts the crossover at $20 to $40M in revenue.
A reseller takes its cut as a wholesale discount of 40 to 65% off retail, by Amplifyr's count (Amazon management agency). Amplifyr and Witz Group (Amazon marketplace partner) both say control of pricing and listings passes to the reseller.
Our judgment
- Run Amazon yourself while it sells under about $1M a year. That rests on SalesDuo's cash-cost view, Andrew Youderian's advice on ads under $500K a year, and Amazon's free Seller Assistant and ad automation.
- From about $1M to $15M to $20M a year, keep one in-house owner and rent specialist work. The owner holds strategy, inventory and the account. This follows PPC Jumpstart's and Evolve Media's advice and SalesDuo's split of strategy in house and specialists outside.
- Count the agency fee in Amazon's profit before you renew. An eCommerceFuel member found Amazon barely profitable once fees were added, and Drew Fallon set a $60K a month agency against two hires.
- Use a reseller only when you accept giving up control of price, listings and customer data. That draws on Amplifyr's 40 to 65% wholesale discount and its and Witz Group's account of how control shifts.
Our judgment, built from SalesDuo, Andrew Youderian, Amazon, PPC Jumpstart, Evolve Media Agency, Drew Fallon, Amplifyr and Witz Group: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 9 sourcesDrew Fallon dropped Mad Rabbit's Amazon agency, which cost roughly $60K a month, because he could hire two full-time people for two thirds of that. It is one example with no before and after results.
“he could hire two full-time people for two thirds of that”
Andrew Youderian says eComFuel members under $500K a year in ad spend should bring ads in-house; members who dropped agencies report flat or higher sales, mostly on Amazon and Google.
“Small to medium-sized brands see big gains bringing ads in-house. If you're under $500K in annual ad spend you should, too.”
Amplifyr, an Amazon agency, puts full-service management at $2,500 to $15,000 a month (3 to 10% of revenue) and PPC-only at $1,000 to $3,000. Resellers take 40 to 65% off retail plus control. No sample.
“The price is control.”
PPC Land reports Amazon's Seller Assistant adding round-the-clock pricing and restocking automations, a new hand in how ad budgets get spent, and notes Amazon published no method or time savings for its claims.
“No measured time savings are published.”
Amazon says its free Seller Assistant can draft Sponsored Products campaigns and auto-adjust search terms under a seller's max bid; it claims a first sale 40% faster, with no method given.
“In early results, Amazon said, new campaigns using it saw a first sale 40 percent faster.”
SalesDuo, an Amazon agency, says do it yourself at about $500,000 in yearly Amazon sales, an agency gets competitive near $1 million, and pure DIY is fragile at about $5 million. Planning patterns, not limits.
“These are planning patterns, not hard and fast limits.”
Amazon's Seller Assistant can now run workflows like restocking and pricing on its own within seller limits, with approval before actions. Amazon says sellers accept its recommendations over 90% of the time.
“When it takes actions, sellers stay in control, reviewing and approving them before they're carried out.”
Witz Group, which buys brands' inventory, says an authorized reseller limits a brand's control of price and listings and can go below MAP, but suits brands where Amazon is a small share. No data.
“pricing can fall below MAP when multiple sellers compete for the Buy Box.”
PPC Jumpstart, which sells Amazon PPC management, says an agency is usually cheaper for brands under about $2M a year on Amazon, and in-house pays only above $15 to $20M.
“If Amazon is only 20-30% of a multi-channel business, an agency is almost always the better use of capital.”
Evolve Media, which sells Amazon agency services, estimates an in-house Amazon team at $400K to $700K a year versus $30K to $120K for an agency, with in-house winning from about $20 to $40M revenue.
“Below $20M revenue, the math almost always favors agencies.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer