Which ad styles and formats should we be producing this month?
Our answer
Build offer-first statics and product images with text before your Black Friday sale opens, and hold them until it does (Budgets and launch timing for seasonal peaks). Keep always-on ads value-led, built on demos, testimonials, creator and founder videos.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 1 Meta rule, 6 datasets, 14 practitioners, 6 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 19 sources
- 28 statements
MDDFC
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentOffer-first banners win often and take a large share of spend. They had an 8.6% hit rate and took 29.3% of spend in Motion's 2026 benchmark, but its window includes Black Friday.
Brands that make more Black Friday ads spend more on them. Across 74 brands, one with twice as many Black Friday ads as a brand its size spent about 36% more on them, with ROAS about 2% lower per doubling (Common Thread Collective).
Founder content can work or flop depending on the buyer. Dara Denney ranks founder content and partnership ads top tier. Yet founder content that carried Lomi for two years flopped at Pela, whose primary buyers are young women (Cody Plofker's account of Matt Bertulli's brands).
Our judgment
- Make demos and testimonials the steady base of always-on ads. Motion calls them baseline workhorse formats, with hit rates of 8.1% and 6.5% and spend in line with their share of ads.
- Use creator talk-to-camera and founder videos to reach new people. We extend Dara Denney's advice for multi-million-dollar-a-month brands and Savannah Sanchez's view of talk-to-camera ads to all spend levels, alongside HexClad's move from offer ads to evergreen and creator-led ads in its Japan market.
- Test founder videos with your own buyers before making them a base. The same founder's content worked at one brand and flopped at another with different buyers.
- Prefer human-made ads over fully AI-generated ones in every country. This extends the US test by Ipsos and Syracuse University.
Our judgment, built from Motion, Dara Denney, Savannah Sanchez, Marketing Operators podcast, Matt Bertulli (via Cody Plofker) and Ipsos and Syracuse University: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
28 statements from 19 sourcesFraser Cottrell ranks ad styles from screenshots he has collected: lo-fi phone ads, reviews over product shots and talking-head ads at the top, brand films that never say what the product does at the bottom.
“The ugly iPhone ad outspending everything else in the account”
A newsletter relays one brand that ran a sitewide sale without mentioning it in ads: existing ads got more revenue per dollar and lower cost per purchase, and spend scaled to 4 times usual. No figures.
Phil Kiel says Black Friday ads should show people who know you the sale, deadline, product and offer in the first seconds, while evergreen ads with a banner and new headline handle new people.
“People who don't know you need too much explaining for a Black Friday ad.”
Lorenzo Pravata says one brand went from $6K on Meta in April to $392K a month by July with funnel, pricing and LTV unchanged. Three of its top five ads were podcast clips; only 3 of 16 scripts worked at first.
“Yet in month one, only 3 of our 16 scripts performed.”
Cody Plofker relays that founder ads carried Lomi for its first two years but flopped at Pela, whose main buyers are young women: the same tactic gave opposite results. No figures.
“At Lomi, founder ads carried the business for the first two years.”
Meta's image ad page says there is no longer a limit on text in ad images. It advises only that text not obstruct the visuals, and mentions no delivery or cost penalty for text-heavy images.
“There is no longer a limit on the amount of text that can exist in your ad image.”
Aazar Ali Shad says a founder's best ad of 2026 was a product photo with six words, which beat every polished asset across campaigns and three countries. One account, no numbers.
“The best performing ad a founder showed me this year was a product photo with six words on it.”
Operators podcast guests list 10 tactics for a new brand at about $200 CAC, including founder-led creative, fewer AI ads, coached creators with whitelisted content and testing offers and landing pages.
“New brand; no track record; ~$200 CAC.”
Fraser Cottrell's Black Friday advice from CPG accounts: add a sale banner to your top 5 evergreen ads, run lots of offer-led statics, and keep making evergreen ads with one Black Friday variation.
Meta says more than 60% of time on Facebook and Instagram is spent watching video, and Advantage+ creative can now make video from static images. Meta grading its own product.
“more than 60% of the time people spend on Facebook and Instagram is spent with video”
Meta's own paper on 20 EMEA lift studies says cells with at least 30% partnership ad assets had 45% lower median cost per incremental purchase. PPC Land notes the claims are Meta's own.
“advertisers mixing at least 30% partnership ads into business-as-usual campaigns recorded a 45% lower median cost per incremental purchase across 20 EMEA conversion lift studies”
Biddyco's large US Meta accounts saw consumer-brand CPMs rise 35% in the week of Nov 24 and 57% on Black Friday versus October. It says holiday ads should be live and learning by early November.
“belongs in the September or October batch”
Taylor Holiday says the peak holiday buying window runs Wednesday to Monday, and starting sales earlier mostly discounts people who would have bought anyway.
Jay Wright says founders who are their own ideal customer get a performance boost by appearing on camera in their ads.
“you will get a performance boost if you ... are your ideal customer profile and you can actually step in front of the camera”
Pep Hufen says that of 12 creatives tested, an unscripted founder video demonstrating the product has been the best performer for about 60 days.
“what I didn't expect was actually that one of the unscripted videos has been the best performer for basically the last 60 days.”
In CTC's data on 74 brands' Meta holiday seasons, doubling Black Friday ads raised Black Friday spend about 36% with ROAS only about 2% lower. Brands at $183K to $734K a month ran a median 209 Black Friday ads.
“launch more ads, earlier, so Meta has more candidates”
Meta's 2026 holiday guidance is to have Advantage+ campaigns with creator content live by mid-October; CTC says they need 6 to 8 weeks of learning before Black Friday.
Dara Denney ranks partnership (creator) ads top tier and says brands spending millions a month should use them to reach new people when rolling monthly reach falls.
Dara Denney ranks founder content top and catalog ads strong; generic problem-solution UGC, AI avatars and AI animation sit in the middle, with carousels and podcast-style ads near the bottom.
Harry Delmege says accounts spending 200k and up tend to run a very diverse creative mix: founder content, talking-head ads, AI statics and performance UGC.
“big spend is it's definitely like very diverse content”
A Marketing Operators guest says shifting from offer-focused ads to evergreen and creator-led creative trained the algorithm to reach new people, reaching a 20% net new visitor rate.
“the big thing this year was launching more evergreen creative and just like training the algorithm to go and reach more new people, which we've successfully done.”
Savannah Sanchez says talk-to-camera yapper ads are the hot format of mid-2026, and creator whitelisting and partnership ads work even better this year.
Motion's Zach Stuck says a full-body ad showing a person physically using the product, such as putting on compression socks, outperformed talking-head close-ups.
“full frame body shot of someone talking”
Richard Gaffin says Post-It Note ads, a product photo with a handwritten note stating the offer, work well during promotions.
“what we're finding is that Post-It Note ads work really well”
In an Ipsos test of 3,000 US people, human-made ads scored 14% higher short term and 17% higher long term than fully AI-made versions. It is survey-based ad testing, not live ad delivery.
“14% stronger on short-term effectiveness”
Motion's 2026 benchmarks of 578,750 ads: offer-first banners had an 8.6% hit rate and took 29.3% of spend on 21.9% of ads; unboxing hit 9.8%, demos 8.1%, testimonials 6.5%.
“Offer-First Banner is strong on both.”
Motion's 2026 benchmark of 578,750 ads finds text-only and product-image-with-text ads lead on hit rate and spend share, UGC ranks 4th, and carousels and animation rank last.
Motion's benchmark of 578,750 ads found promotional hooks (newness, sales, price anchors, urgency) had the highest hit rates, 6-11%, though Motion says its holiday data window inflates them.
“Promotional hooks are over-represented.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer